Leading Actress: Drama

Carmela Soprano's charm in play for last time

As shows get rubbed out, others get penciled in.

And with that, the sense of a changing of the guard is hovering over this year’s drama lead actress nominees, most notably from the awards juggernaut “The Sopranos” ending and the nearly perennial nominee and three-time winner Edie Falco up for a last at bat as Carmela Soprano.

Plus half of the six nominees are looking to win their first award in this category.

Of the newcomers, Sally Field (for “Brothers & Sisters”) and Minnie Driver (“The Riches”) seem like different ends of a wider spectrum for female roles on television, with Field representing tried-and-true network drama in all its glowing likability and Driver bringing to this category a harder-edged, slightly more dangerous cable-fied charisma.

Second-year-in-a-row nominee Kyra Sedgwick (“The Closer”), meanwhile, looks to win her first for breathing personality into the typically cold police procedural, something that garnered Mariska Hargitay (“Law & Order: Special Victims Unit”) her first win last year after seven seasons and three nominations.

In fact, the past two years’ winners — Patricia Arquette (“Medium”) and Hargitay — are back, again signifying the Academy’s preference for keeping awardees in the loop. Arquette, however, was left out of the noms last year, which was a strange occurrence, considering her first-year leap into the prizewinners circle — but perhaps indicative of the breadth of talent in this category. There are six nominees this year, after all, one more than the usual five.

Patricia Arquette
Show: “Medium”
Emmy pedigree: One win
Best scene: Nearly all of “The One Behind the Wheel,” in which Arquette with virtuosity plays a haughty rich wife named Sandra unknowingly trapped in psychic Alison DuBois’ body.
Why she may win: Week in, week out, Arquette does solid, committed work as the most believable everyday wife/mother on television while selling the psychic powers stuff as well.
Maybe not: Having nabbed this prize previously, voters may decide to hold off before celebrating her work again so soon.

Minnie Driver
Show: “The Riches”
Emmy pedigree: First nom
Best scene: In the pilot, Driver’s fresh-out-of-prison, secretly drug-addicted con artist mother Dahlia drives herself to tears trying not to shoot up in their new, stolen McMansion, then lets herself be comforted by a friendly new neighbor who introduces Dahlia to the joys of happy pills.
Why she may win: If voters are in a mood to anoint an edgy newcomer, Brit-born Driver is that choice. She instantly set herself apart with her combination of vice, vim and vulnerability, plus a spot-on Southern accent.
Maybe not: It’s a prickly character, and “The Riches” is not as high profile a show as the other nominees.

Edie Falco
Show: “The Sopranos”
Emmy pedigree: Three wins plus two other noms
Best scene: In “Chasing It,” after Tony blows up at Carmela for not letting him put her first house sale earnings on a sports bet, she tearily confronts him over her insecurity about being left a financially desperate widow. It’s a classic Falco moment: full of fierce love and wide-eyed vulnerability.
Why she may win: She was snubbed for a nomination last year and could ride final-season hype toward a momentous four-win send-off.
Maybe not: This was a mostly Carmela-less season, with the emphasis on Tony’s increasingly conflicted soul.

Sally Field
Show: “Brothers & Sisters”
Emmy pedigree: Two wins plus three other noms
Best scene: In the season’s final episode, “Matriarchy,” Field brings heartbreaking sadness to a kitchen moment when Nora refuses to accept son Justin’s wish that he say goodbye to her before leaving for Iraq.
Why she may win: The breakout star of “Brothers & Sisters” turned out to be the flinty yet unquestionably loving matriarch. Showbiz vet Field anchored nearly every episode with her skilled comic timing and emotional range.
Maybe not: Field is a two-time Oscar winner and two-time Emmy winner, going back to the landmark miniseries “Sybil,” which puts a qualification on her newcomer status.

Mariska Hargitay
Show: “Law & Order: SVU”
Emmy pedigree: One win plus two other noms
Best scene: In “Florida,” Olivia learns the truth about her father Joe and half-brother Simon, both accused of rape.
Why she may win: After eight seasons, Hargitay hasn’t shown character fatigue and seems to only generate more fans.
Maybe not: Familiarity. Academy voters know this particular “L&O” brand will be around a while longer, which could send voters toward new blood.

Kyra Sedgwick
Show: “The Closer”
Emmy pedigree: One nom
Best scene: From “Slippin’,” a solemn Det. Brenda Johnson explains to Sgt. Gabriel how to deliver news to unsuspecting parents that their son is dead.
Why she may win: Sedgwick has galvanized original basic cable programming with her tough, compassionate, headstrong and neurotic Southern-belle cop.
Maybe not: Voters might also have crime solver fatigue from Hargitay winning last year and Arquette the year prior.

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Scene News from Variety