Review: ‘Donnie Darko’

Geoff Shaevitz

Poor Donnie Darko. First, the troubled teen is on meds for psychological problems. Then a 6-foot rabbit tells him the world is going to end. Then a jet engine crashes into his bedroom. Then his movie is adapted to the stage. Sometimes a kid just can't get a break.

Poor Donnie Darko. First, the troubled teen is on meds for psychological problems. Then a 6-foot rabbit tells him the world is going to end. Then a jet engine crashes into his bedroom. Then his movie is adapted to the stage. Sometimes a kid just can’t get a break.

Richard Kelly’s enigmatic 2001 cult film, which combines high school angst with science fiction, teen romance and quirky comedy, would seem a natural for a student-rich market and an adventuresome theater like A.R.T. Indeed, workshops of the show in helmer Marcus Stern’s acting class created enough buzz to get the green light for a full production on the company’s second stage, which is becoming a home for works aimed to attract a younger audience. This year, the terrific “The Onion Cellar” (also helmed by Stern) bowed there as well as a popular hip-vaudeville show.

But not all films can make the transition from screen to stage. That’s the case here in a production best described as an intriguing exercise that doesn’t work.

At worst, it’s a scattershot endeavor with uneven perfs, awkward script choices and cumbersome staging. There are several nice visual elements such as the jet crash, done via a dollhouse with an actor holding a toy airplane. But even the cool musical score (much of it lifted from the movie) fails to energize the story, save for the haunting “Mad World” which ends the film and stage show.

Though the “what does it mean?” factor fueled obsessive talk about the film, it sometimes obscured a work of fine craftsmanship, a script that captured a teen world of a certain time (1988) and a captivating perf by a young Jake Gyllenhaal. Just looking into the actor’s troubled eyes in the film’s close-ups and stillnesses you could almost enter his confused mind (and also find a compatriot in confusion).

While in the stage version the lanky Dan McCabe looks right, the audience is not drawn into the character’s troubled soul. Not that he’s given much time to make that connection because the actor is too busy dashing back and forth on the vast stage and zipping us through the 70-plus scene narrative. (The show is a souped-up 80 minutes.)

Kelly’s mixture of styles, so perfectly balanced on film, is played more as a goof on stage, with the comic-book elements dominating the tone at the expense of the more realistic aspects. The one extended scene with Donnie and girlfriend-to-be (Flora Diaz) at a bus stop is almost startling in its unexpected honesty.

As for the metaphysical elements, they remain as open to interpretation as in the film. But they aren’t the stage work’s challenge. Anyone unfamiliar with the original might find even the basic narrative difficult to follow, especially in terms of the characters’ relationships with one another.

Donnie’s family is sketchily portrayed in deep exaggeration: Donnie’s little sister Samantha is played by a young woman in pigtails (Carolyn McCandlish); mom (Paula Langton) is a wine-loving lush; his classmates are cartoons (he’s minus his best friends); and authority figures are beyond archetypes — though at least Karen MacDonald as righteous Kitty Farmer and Thomas Derrah as the smarmy motivational speaker know how to enliven a scene.

Though the stage is populated with 19 actors (only half of them Equity members, and sadly, that shows with some painfully thin perfs), it’s still not enough to fill the film’s high school and suburban world. It’s a mad, weird place still best viewed — and contemplated — onscreen. Stern doesn’t succeed in creating an equally intriguing parallel universe on the stage.

Donnie Darko

Zero Arrow Theater, Cambridge, Mass.; 300 seats; $52 top


An American Repertory Theater presentation of a play in one act written and directed by Marcus Stern, based on the screenplay by Richard Kelly.


Sets, Matt McAdon; costumes, Clint Ramos; lighting, Scott Zielinski; sound, David Remedios, Stern; production stage manager, Katherine Shea. Opened Oct. 31, 2007. Reviewed Nov. 1. Runs through Nov. 18. Running time: 1 HOUR, 20 MIN.


Donnie Darko - Dan McCabe Gretchen Ross - Flora Diaz Rose Darko - Paula Langton Eddie Darko - Will LeBow Samantha Darko - Carolyn McCandlish Elizabeth Darko - Angela Nahigian Dr. Lilian Thurman - Mara Sidmore Jim Cunningham - Thomas Derrah Kitty Farmer - Karen MacDonald Principal Cole - Remo Airaldi Rabbit, Frank - Perry Jackson
With: Sarah Jorge Leon, Delance Minifee, Thomas Kelley, Kathy Lebron, Talisa Friedman, Greta Merchant, Gillian Gordon, Lisa Woods.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Legit News from Variety