Review: ‘The Water Horse’

Taking the legend of the Loch Ness monster out for an engaging ride, "The Water Horse" benefits from a strong sense of time and place, lush photography and committed performances.

Taking the legend of the Loch Ness monster out for an engaging ride, “The Water Horse” benefits from a strong sense of time and place (WWII-era Scotland), lush photography and committed performances — not least from the initially cute, finally fearsome CG creature of the film’s title. Though it strikes some predictable coming-of-age notes, this moving, well-wrought adventure should appeal to fans of “E.T.” and Carroll Ballard, though as Ballard’s pics have proven, quality is no guarantee of an audience in this genre. Careful handling will be needed for the family-friendly Sony release to register more than a B.O. splash.

Scenarist Robert Nelson Jacobs (“The Shipping News,” “Chocolat”) has brought some conventional dramatic hooks to bear on Dick King-Smith’s slim tale about a 1930s family adopting an increasingly hard-to-manage sea monster — namely, making the story’s protagonist a lonely, emotionally troubled young tyke and recasting the events against the war-torn ’40s.

Set in the Scottish region bordering the giant lake known as Loch Ness, the boy-meets-egg saga kicks off with Angus MacMorrow (Alex Etel, “Millions”) discovering a rock-encrusted object washed ashore one morning, which he takes back to the sprawling estate where he lives with his housekeeper mom Anne (an excellent Emily Watson) and older sister Kirstie (Priyanka Xi). When a purplish creature resembling a baby dinosaur hatches from the egg, Angus immediately decides to secretly adopt the raucous little beastie.

Crusoe, as Angus names the slimy castaway, has a horselike snout, webbed feet, Shrek-like ears and a marked affinity for water. (There are also traces of dog, eagle and giraffe present, at least according to the press notes.) Eating and growing at a persuasively alarming rate, the creature soon gets too big for the bathtub, threatening discovery by Angus’ stern mother.

Complicating matters are the British soldiers stationed at the house, under the rather bogus pretext that German subs are expected to pass through the loch. While Anne flirts with the dashing but smug Capt. Hamilton (David Morrissey), the script duly trots out handsome, hard-drinking handyman Lewis Mowbry (Ben Chaplin), who bonds with Angus and Kirstie, helps them keep Crusoe a secret, turns out to have a military record even more distinguished than the captain’s, and in general couldn’t be more likable to auds if he defeated Hitler singlehandedly.

Yet despite the obvious setups — and the potential mawkishness of Angus’ memories of his dad (played by Craig Hall in flashback) before the latter left for the frontlines, never to return — “The Water Horse” never drowns in bathos. Director Jay Russell (who also helmed such family fare as “Tuck Everlasting” and “My Dog Skip”) displays a sensitive touch with conventional material, nurturing the story’s slapstick potential (i.e., when a soldier’s dog realizes there’s another animal on the premises) without going overboard.

Just as the creature quickly swells from pint-size pet to gargantuan behemoth, necessitating its relocation to the Loch Ness, so the film transitions seamlessly from a gently spirited comedy to a harrowing drama that might prove frightening to especially wee tots. As Angus fights to protect Crusoe from the eyes and cannons of the British militia, the pic quietly captures the frustration and dangers that plagued even those on the sidelines of the Good War, most notably in Watson’s deeply felt performance as a single mother struggling to hold on to her sanity.

Vividly rendered by the visual-effects artists of Weta Digital (also behind “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy and “The Chronicles of Narnia” franchise which, like this film, was produced by Walden Media), with especially close attention paid to the creature’s gradual metamorphosis, Crusoe never quite makes viewers forget they’re watching a ginormous special effect, but comes close enough to establish the poignant, all-important bond between boy and beast. Supporting thesps are uniformly strong, including Brian Cox in an affectionate turn as the story’s present-day narrator.

Oliver Stapleton’s sweeping widescreen compositions are gorgeous enough to jumpstart Scottish tourism (though New Zealand locations subbed extensively), while the surging score by James Newton Howard (who turned in subtler work on this year’s “Michael Clayton”) overdoses a bit on the bagpipes and Celtic overtones.

Though the pic is being marketed as “The Water Horse: Legend of the Deep,” the title on the print screened read simply “The Water Horse.”

The Water Horse



A Sony Pictures Entertainment (in U.S.) release of a Revolution Studios, Walden Media, Beacon Pictures (U.S.) presentation of an Ecosse Films (U.K.) production. Produced by Robert Bernstein, Douglas Rae, Barrie M. Osborne, Charlie Lyons. Executive producers, Charles Newirth, Jay Russell. Directed by Jay Russell. Screenplay, Robert Nelson Jacobs, based on the book by Dick King-Smith.


Camera (Deluxe color, Arri widescreen), Oliver Stapleton; editor, Mark Warner; music, James Newton Howard; theme written and performed by Sinead O'Connor; music supervisor, Denise Luiso; production designer, Tony Burrough; supervising art director, Dan Hennah; art directors, Brad Mill, Simon Bright; set designers, Philip Thomas; set decorator, Hennah; costume designer, John Bloomfield; sound (Dolby Digital/SDDS/DTS), Tony Johnson; supervising sound editors, Dave Whitehead, Jason Canovas; sound designer, Whitehead; re-recording mixers, Michael Hedges, Tom Johnson; senior visual effects supervisor, Joe Letteri; visual effects supervisors, Stephen Rosenbaum, R. Christopher White, Erik Winquist; visual effects, Weta Digital; stunt coordinator, Augie Davis; assistant director, Vincent Lascoumes; second unit director, John Mahaffie; casting, Susie Figgis; New Zealand casting, Liz Mullane. Reviewed at Sony studios, Culver City. Nov. 29, 2007. MPAA Rating: PG. Running time: 111 MIN.


Anne MacMorrow - Emily Watson Angus MacMorrow - Alex Etel Lewis Mowbray - Ben Chaplin Capt. Hamilton - David Morrissey Kirstie MacMorrow - Priyanka Xi Sgt. Strunk - Marshall Napier Sgt. Walker - Joel Tobeck Lt. Wormsley - Erroll Shand Old Angus - Brian Cox
With: Craig Hall.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety