Review: ‘The Mourning Forest’

Grief seeks relief in beautifully mounted, but ponderous, mood piece from Japan's Naomi Kawase.

Grief seeks relief in this beautifully mounted but ponderous mood piece from Japan’s Naomi Kawase. Yarn about a young caregiver who follows an elderly patient into the forest strives for the mythic, but the pic’s ambition is undercut by its conveniently underarticulated affectations. With reverential critics the minority at Cannes, pic emerged the surprise winner of the 2007 Grand Prix. Prize will give a considerable boost to both the helmer and her latest effort, but commercial prospects beyond the Parisian and Tokyo arthouse circuits are unlikely. Fests will no doubt follow Cannes’ suit and make this a wish-list must-have.

In the mountainous region west of Nara, Machiko (Machiko Ono) is adjusting to her new role as caregiver at an old folks’ home. Burdened by the death of her young son, Machiko is drawn to dementia-affected patient Shigeki (Shigeki Uda). With only a syllable separating the name of the caregiver and Shigeki’s dead wife of 33 years, Mako, the unruly patient is similarly attracted to the new staff member.

While taking Shigeki out for a birthday drive, Machiko experiences engine trouble. Machiko leaves the old man briefly to seek help at a nearby farmhouse, and her charge takes the opportunity to grab his precious backpack and bolt into the wilderness. Machiko has no choice but to follow. Quickly becoming lost in the forest, the duo must contend, overnight, with the elements, while Shigeki is propelled forward on an unknown quest.

Like many classical Japanese artists for centuries before her, Kawase is clearly inspired by nature. Punctuating the helmer’s slight, slow script are gorgeous images of fields and forests that imbue the pic with a haiku sensibility. Unfortunately, Kawase’s spiritual themes seem more calculated than heartfelt. Aud endurance is tested by a directing style that is by turns hamfistedly deliberate and annoyingly tentative. The latter mode creates an ad hoc, undisciplined feel, like Terrence Malick at his most easily distracted.

Lensing by Hideyo Nakano is exquisite, vividly capturing a primal energy.

Thesps are as wooden as the trees around them and fail to transcend their roles as ciphers for the helmer’s vague vision. Tech credits are pro.

The Mourning Forest



A Dreamachine presentation of a Kumie production in co-production with Celluloid Dreams Prods. (France)/Visual Arts College Osaka (Japan), with the participation of the Centre National de la Cinematographie (France)/the Cultural Agency (Japan). (International sales: Dreamachine, Paris.) Produced by Naomi Kawase. Executive producer, Hengameh Panahi. Directed, written by Naomi Kawase.


Camera (color), Hideyo Nakano; editor, Yuji Oshige, Tina Baz; music, Masamichi Shigeno; art director, Toshihiro Isomi; sound, (Dolby SR Digital); Shigetake Ao, David Vranken. Reviewed at Cannes Film Festival (in competition), May. 27, 2007. Running time: 97 MIN.


Shigeki Uda, Machiko Ono, Makiko Ono, Kanako Masuda, Yoichiro Saito.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety