Nuremberg: The Nazis Facing Their Crimes

"Nuremberg: The Nazis Facing Their Crimes" is a curiously low-key condensation of the Nuremberg trial, culled almost exclusively from courtroom footage filmed under the supervision of John Ford (now digitally remastered), which fascinates with its dry avoidance of drama -- those rare moments of emotional intensity threatening to tear apart the layers of judicial dispassion in which the tribunal swathed itself.

With:
With: Hermann Goering, Rudolf Hess, Budd Schulberg, Robert H. Jackson. Narrator: Christopher Plummer. (English, German, Russian, French dialogue)

“Nuremberg: The Nazis Facing Their Crimes” is a curiously low-key condensation of the Nuremberg trial, culled almost exclusively from courtroom footage filmed under the supervision of John Ford (now digitally remastered), which fascinates with its dry avoidance of drama — those rare moments of emotional intensity threatening to tear apart the layers of judicial dispassion in which the tribunal swathed itself. Pic’s procedural emphasis first appears irrelevant to its avowed subject, yet the red tape-clogged, precedent-setting proceedings manifest a stubborn will toward clarity that feels strangely appropriate. Rewarding to patient viewers, “Nuremberg” should find a stable berth on television.

Those drawn to the film by its subtitle will doubtless be disappointed by the lack of concentrated focus on the reactions, or absence of reactions, of the SS defendants in the dock. But in fact, French director Christian Delage has a hidden agenda that, in retrospect, clarifies the thrust of his 90-minute edit.

As a historian, Delage is obsessed with the growing role of reproduced images in shaping history. In this light, the emphasis on the myriad cameras recording the trial as well as the documentaries-within-documentaries screened in the courtroom (showing concentration camps as well as the slaughter of civilians and POWs in Russia) begins to make structural sense.

At the same time, the trial is inseparable from these projected images — which, moved up on the docket to spark flagging interest in the slow-moving proceedings, shocked the courtroom, and sent figures filing out in silence once the lights came back on.

Contrary to the depiction in Hollywood’s Spencer Tracy-Judy Garland starrer “Judgment at Nuremberg,” testimony by victims was surprisingly sparse, as it seemed to discomfit members of the tribunal. A female survivor, mastering her emotion as she adamantly recounts what she witnessed at Auschwitz (her account culminating with the screams of children thrown into ovens alive), is interrupted by a judge before she can move on to her experiences at Ravensbruch, on the supposition of redundancy. (The witness dryly disagrees: One was a functional death camp, the other worked people to death.)

Testimony from Nazis immune from indictment proposes horror of a different stripe: One calmly remorseless SD leader responsible for killing 90,000 Russian Jews makes fine distinctions between shooting them up close or at a distance.

Consummately narrated by Christopher Plummer with silky gravitas, docu also highlights the reaction of a stunned world to the atrocities uncovered a mere six months earlier — judges’ and prosecutors’ ringing indictments echoed by citations from the packed rows of international press (a young, mustachioed Walter Cronkite in their midst). Yet in its methodical matter-of-factness, docu cannot but reveal the gap between the vastness of the crime and the narrowness of its punishment.

Nuremberg: The Nazis Facing Their Crimes

France

Production: A Compagnie des Phares et Balises production in co-production with ARTE France. (International sales: Delphis Films, Montreal.) Directed by Christian Delage.

Crew: Camera (B&W archival, color, DV), U.S. military camera crews under John Ford, Francois Dagenais; editor, Stephane Huter; sound, David Lassalle. Reviewed on DVD, New York, Jan. 8, 2007. (In New York Jewish Film Festival.) Running time: 90 MIN.

With: With: Hermann Goering, Rudolf Hess, Budd Schulberg, Robert H. Jackson. Narrator: Christopher Plummer. (English, German, Russian, French dialogue)

More Film

  • Bob Iger Disney

    Disney to Give $1,000 Cash Bonuses to 125,000 Employees

    “Nuremberg: The Nazis Facing Their Crimes” is a curiously low-key condensation of the Nuremberg trial, culled almost exclusively from courtroom footage filmed under the supervision of John Ford (now digitally remastered), which fascinates with its dry avoidance of drama — those rare moments of emotional intensity threatening to tear apart the layers of judicial dispassion […]

  • How to Watch This Year's Oscar-Nominated

    How to Stream This Year's Oscar-Nominated Films

    “Nuremberg: The Nazis Facing Their Crimes” is a curiously low-key condensation of the Nuremberg trial, culled almost exclusively from courtroom footage filmed under the supervision of John Ford (now digitally remastered), which fascinates with its dry avoidance of drama — those rare moments of emotional intensity threatening to tear apart the layers of judicial dispassion […]

  • Ophelia

    Sundance Film Review: 'Ophelia'

    “Nuremberg: The Nazis Facing Their Crimes” is a curiously low-key condensation of the Nuremberg trial, culled almost exclusively from courtroom footage filmed under the supervision of John Ford (now digitally remastered), which fascinates with its dry avoidance of drama — those rare moments of emotional intensity threatening to tear apart the layers of judicial dispassion […]

  • PARK CITY, UT - JANUARY 22:

    Sundance: 'The Tale' Filmmakers on Sexual Abuse Drama: 'The World Is Ready to Look at This Difficult Subject'

    “Nuremberg: The Nazis Facing Their Crimes” is a curiously low-key condensation of the Nuremberg trial, culled almost exclusively from courtroom footage filmed under the supervision of John Ford (now digitally remastered), which fascinates with its dry avoidance of drama — those rare moments of emotional intensity threatening to tear apart the layers of judicial dispassion […]

  • Studio 54

    Sundance Film Review: 'Studio 54'

    “Nuremberg: The Nazis Facing Their Crimes” is a curiously low-key condensation of the Nuremberg trial, culled almost exclusively from courtroom footage filmed under the supervision of John Ford (now digitally remastered), which fascinates with its dry avoidance of drama — those rare moments of emotional intensity threatening to tear apart the layers of judicial dispassion […]

  • Oscars 2018 Nominations: Who Are the

    Oscar Nominations Are in, but Who Are the Frontrunners?

    “Nuremberg: The Nazis Facing Their Crimes” is a curiously low-key condensation of the Nuremberg trial, culled almost exclusively from courtroom footage filmed under the supervision of John Ford (now digitally remastered), which fascinates with its dry avoidance of drama — those rare moments of emotional intensity threatening to tear apart the layers of judicial dispassion […]

  • 'Get Out' Breaks Out With Four

    'Get Out' Scores Four Oscar Nominations, Including Three for Jordan Peele

    “Nuremberg: The Nazis Facing Their Crimes” is a curiously low-key condensation of the Nuremberg trial, culled almost exclusively from courtroom footage filmed under the supervision of John Ford (now digitally remastered), which fascinates with its dry avoidance of drama — those rare moments of emotional intensity threatening to tear apart the layers of judicial dispassion […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content