The Heart of the Earth

Politics and passion unite in time-honored style in Antonio Cuadri's sweeping historical yarn "The Heart of the Earth." Unfortunately, almost everything else about the pic is time-honored too, giving it a deja-vu flavor despite its eco-message. Concept is superb but the script rushes through the historical facts in the first half-hour and then becomes far-fetched in its invented stretches.

With:
With: Catalina Sandino Moreno, Sienna Guillory, Philip Winchester, Bernard Hill, Joaquim de Almeida, Ana Fernandez, Jorge Perugorria, Fernando Ramallo, Natalia Quesnel. (Spanish dialogue)

Politics and passion unite in time-honored style in Antonio Cuadri’s sweeping historical yarn “The Heart of the Earth.” Unfortunately, almost everything else about the pic is time-honored too, giving it a deja-vu flavor despite its eco-message. Concept is superb — the tragic, real-life 19th-century suppression of a Spanish copper miners’ rebellion by their British employees — but the script rushes through the historical facts in the first half-hour and then becomes far-fetched in its invented stretches. Still, breathtaking scenery and top-notch production values make this a visual treat, partly redeeming a mainstream project with slender international prospects.

In 1887, in Huelva, Spain, spirited lass Kathleen (Natalia Quesnel) is being brought up by her tyrannical uncle, Mr. Crown (Bernard Hill), manager of the Rio Tinto copper mines. The mines emit toxic fumes which are poisoning the locals, but Crown doesn’t care. When a Cuban revolutionary mysteriously arrives to whip up a protest, Crown brings in the military, who massacre the protesters.

That’s enough material for a long feature. But here it’s compressed into half an hour, with characterization the first casualty.

Fifteen years later, Baxter (Joaquim de Almeida) arrives, accompanied by bodyguard Robert (Philip Winchester), to take over from Crown. Robert becomes the love interest for the older Kathleen (Sienna Guillory) and her free-thinking teacher friend, Blanca (Catalina Sandino Moreno). The seeds of rebellion in the town are again being sown by Carlos (baby-faced Fernando Ramallo, miscast) and Baxter will have to decide whether to be tyrant or liberal.

Heavily populated pic has plenty of conflict, but too little is sufficiently developed to grip, with actors struggling to make a mark. Several roles are surplus to dramatic requirements, while Spanish thesp Ana Fernandez, playing Blanca’s mother (who loses her wits after the revolutionary’s death), is completely stranded.

Visually, the pic is pretty much faultless, particularly the stunning aerial shots of the mines. Music is lushly orchestral, constantly at a high emotional pitch and rarely subtle. Film features several flashbacks that provide little fresh impetus, while the final reel is heavy with unearned emotion.

The Heart of the Earth

Spain - U.K. - Portugal

Production: An On Pictures release (in Spain) of a Manufacturas Audiovisuales (Spain)/Future Films (U.K.)/Costa do Castelo (Portugal) production, with participation of Canal Sur, TV3, ETB, IC, IB3, TelkeMadrid, Canal 9, Canal Plus. (International sales: Sequence Film/IAC Films, London.) Produced by Antonio Cuadri, Juan Carlos Orihuela, William Dietrich, Stephen Margolis. Executive producers, Luis Angel Bellaba, Emilio A. Pina. Directed by Antonio Cuadri. Screenplay, Cuadri, Shelley Miller, Doc Comparato, based on a novel by Juan Cobos Wilkins.

Crew: Camera (color, widescreen), Javier Salmones; editor, Mercedes Cantero; music, Fernando Orti; art director, Luis Manuel Carmona; sound, Aitor Berenguer. Reviewed at Cines Acteon, Madrid, April 25, 2007. Running time: 91 MIN.

With: With: Catalina Sandino Moreno, Sienna Guillory, Philip Winchester, Bernard Hill, Joaquim de Almeida, Ana Fernandez, Jorge Perugorria, Fernando Ramallo, Natalia Quesnel. (Spanish dialogue)

More Film

  • Solo A Star Wars Story

    'Solo: A Star Wars Story' Stumbles Overseas With $65 Million Launch

    Politics and passion unite in time-honored style in Antonio Cuadri’s sweeping historical yarn “The Heart of the Earth.” Unfortunately, almost everything else about the pic is time-honored too, giving it a deja-vu flavor despite its eco-message. Concept is superb — the tragic, real-life 19th-century suppression of a Spanish copper miners’ rebellion by their British employees […]

  • 'Solo': What That Surprise Cameo Means

    'Solo': What a 'Character Too Secret to Ever Name' Means for the 'Star Wars' Spinoff

    Politics and passion unite in time-honored style in Antonio Cuadri’s sweeping historical yarn “The Heart of the Earth.” Unfortunately, almost everything else about the pic is time-honored too, giving it a deja-vu flavor despite its eco-message. Concept is superb — the tragic, real-life 19th-century suppression of a Spanish copper miners’ rebellion by their British employees […]

  • Solo A Star Wars Story

    Box Office: 'Solo: A Star Wars Story' Looks to Edge Past $100 Million For Holiday Weekend

    Politics and passion unite in time-honored style in Antonio Cuadri’s sweeping historical yarn “The Heart of the Earth.” Unfortunately, almost everything else about the pic is time-honored too, giving it a deja-vu flavor despite its eco-message. Concept is superb — the tragic, real-life 19th-century suppression of a Spanish copper miners’ rebellion by their British employees […]

  • Rebel Wilson and Taye Diggs

    Concert Review: 'Beauty and the Beast' Gets Adoring Tribute at Hollywood Bowl

    Politics and passion unite in time-honored style in Antonio Cuadri’s sweeping historical yarn “The Heart of the Earth.” Unfortunately, almost everything else about the pic is time-honored too, giving it a deja-vu flavor despite its eco-message. Concept is superb — the tragic, real-life 19th-century suppression of a Spanish copper miners’ rebellion by their British employees […]

  • Solo a Star Wars Story Deadpool

    It's Official: Deadpool Is Now Cooler Than Han Solo

    Politics and passion unite in time-honored style in Antonio Cuadri’s sweeping historical yarn “The Heart of the Earth.” Unfortunately, almost everything else about the pic is time-honored too, giving it a deja-vu flavor despite its eco-message. Concept is superb — the tragic, real-life 19th-century suppression of a Spanish copper miners’ rebellion by their British employees […]

  • solo a star wars story

    Box Office: 'Solo: A Star Wars Story' Headed for Underwhelming Holiday Weekend Debut

    Politics and passion unite in time-honored style in Antonio Cuadri’s sweeping historical yarn “The Heart of the Earth.” Unfortunately, almost everything else about the pic is time-honored too, giving it a deja-vu flavor despite its eco-message. Concept is superb — the tragic, real-life 19th-century suppression of a Spanish copper miners’ rebellion by their British employees […]

  • solo a star wars story

    How the Kasdans Settled the Biggest Debate in 'Star Wars' History With 'Solo'

    Politics and passion unite in time-honored style in Antonio Cuadri’s sweeping historical yarn “The Heart of the Earth.” Unfortunately, almost everything else about the pic is time-honored too, giving it a deja-vu flavor despite its eco-message. Concept is superb — the tragic, real-life 19th-century suppression of a Spanish copper miners’ rebellion by their British employees […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content