Web pirate seeks to appeal case

Chan argues HK law doesn't apply to 'Net

HONG KONG — The first man in the world to be charged for distributing movies on the Internet was granted permission to appeal his conviction.

Chan Nai-ming, whose screen name was “Big Crook,” appeared Wednesday before Hong Kong’s highest court, the Court of Final Appeal.

His lawyer argued that the Copyright Ordinance of Hong Kong doesn’t apply to the Internet but instead addresses distributing actual copies of a pirated work. He further argued that Chan only made the copies available for others to download and didn’t actively distribute the films.

Chan was arrested in January 2005 after customs officers found someone had uploaded three movies — “Daredevil,” “Red Planet” and “Miss Congeniality” — to a local BitTorrent discussion forum.

Hearing will resume May 9.

More Digital

  • YouTube’s New Premium Music Service: Is

    YouTube’s New Premium Music Service: Is It Worth It?

    HONG KONG — The first man in the world to be charged for distributing movies on the Internet was granted permission to appeal his conviction. Chan Nai-ming, whose screen name was “Big Crook,” appeared Wednesday before Hong Kong’s highest court, the Court of Final Appeal. His lawyer argued that the Copyright Ordinance of Hong Kong […]

  • Is Spotify Walking Back Its Anti-Hate

    Is Spotify Walking Back Its Anti-Hate Policy?

    HONG KONG — The first man in the world to be charged for distributing movies on the Internet was granted permission to appeal his conviction. Chan Nai-ming, whose screen name was “Big Crook,” appeared Wednesday before Hong Kong’s highest court, the Court of Final Appeal. His lawyer argued that the Copyright Ordinance of Hong Kong […]

  • Iskra Lawrence

    Model Iskra Lawrence to Host 'Mirror Challenge' Docu-Series on Facebook Watch

    HONG KONG — The first man in the world to be charged for distributing movies on the Internet was granted permission to appeal his conviction. Chan Nai-ming, whose screen name was “Big Crook,” appeared Wednesday before Hong Kong’s highest court, the Court of Final Appeal. His lawyer argued that the Copyright Ordinance of Hong Kong […]

  • Facebook Logo

    Facebook Starts Labeling Political Ads in the U.S.

    HONG KONG — The first man in the world to be charged for distributing movies on the Internet was granted permission to appeal his conviction. Chan Nai-ming, whose screen name was “Big Crook,” appeared Wednesday before Hong Kong’s highest court, the Court of Final Appeal. His lawyer argued that the Copyright Ordinance of Hong Kong […]

  • vrcx_bg

    Oculus Go Porn: Adult Industry Has High Hopes for Facebook’s New VR Headset

    HONG KONG — The first man in the world to be charged for distributing movies on the Internet was granted permission to appeal his conviction. Chan Nai-ming, whose screen name was “Big Crook,” appeared Wednesday before Hong Kong’s highest court, the Court of Final Appeal. His lawyer argued that the Copyright Ordinance of Hong Kong […]

  • Movistar +, Netflix, Set Carriage Partnership

    Movistar +, Netflix Strike Carriage Partnership

    HONG KONG — The first man in the world to be charged for distributing movies on the Internet was granted permission to appeal his conviction. Chan Nai-ming, whose screen name was “Big Crook,” appeared Wednesday before Hong Kong’s highest court, the Court of Final Appeal. His lawyer argued that the Copyright Ordinance of Hong Kong […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content