Emmys vs. Oscars

Fashion experts dish about recent looks

Red-carpet winners and losers can provide almost as much drama as the award shows themselves.

We rounded up some fashion experts — stylist Alicia Lawhon; stylist and TV/film costume designer Tom Broecker; and Dino Dinco, co-curator of the You Wear It Well fashion film festival — to dish about recent Emmy and Oscar looks.

FELICITY HUFFMAN AT THE 2005 EMMYS IN KEVAN HALL

Alicia Lawhon: I think this dress would look better if it didn’t have the embellishment. My rule of thumb is if it’s embellished, everything else has to play super clean.

Dino Dinco: It looks kind of like something from Santee Alley. There’s a whole level of messiness going on.

Tom Broecker: I think it’s a great color for her. To me she looks like a ’30s movie star, an updated version of Jean Harlow — and she’s skinny enough to wear that dress.

ELLEN DEGENERES IN VIKTOR & ROLF ONSTAGE AT THE 2005 EMMYS

Tom Broecker: What the cuff is going on? It looks like there are some fitting issues, but my biggest issue is with her shoes. They’re like pilgrim shoes.

Dino Dinco: The flower in the lapel is a nice touch, but it looks like a rental. I know she can afford a bespoke suit. There’s really nothing that separates her as a host from an usher at the Hollywood Bowl.

Alicia Lawhon: I think she looks great. I love the hint of a necklace and the black tuxedo shirt. It’s appropriate for who she is.

SELF-DESCRIBED SCREENWRITER TESS SMITH IN A SYLVIA DANESE ‘GOWN’ AT THE 2005 EMMYS

Dino Dinco: It’s like she ran through a drapery store naked, and that’s what caught on her shoulders.

Tom Broecker: That, to me, looks like a Grammy dress or an MTV dress; it’s a perfect example of not dressing for the event. It’s also a perfect example of dressing for attention.

Alicia Lawhon: Ouch. Even though she’s young and she’s got a great body, this is inappropriate. It’s kind of like those cars that have too many bumper stickers. I think she needs to start doing affirmations.

FELICITY HUFFMAN AT THE 2006 OSCARS IN ZAC POSEN

Tom Broecker: It seems as if she deemed this event more important: I flat-ironed my hair, I pulled it back. But then she cuts the whole thing with this crazy plunging neckline.

Alicia Lawhon: Everything is very well executed. I like the pleats. The detail in the black is really nice. There’s a nice, clean seam, and she wears it well. You can tell she’s really happy in it.

Dino Dinco: Why are we still wearing dresses with trains? It doesn’t seem very modern. I know I’ve stopped.

LAUREN HUTTON IN YSL AT THE 2006 OSCARS

Alicia Lawhon: She’s gorgeous, but she’s exposing you to her dingleberries, which I’m familiar with because my cousin in Mexico has them inside his purple metallic Chevrolet. I don’t want to pick on her, I just want her to look her best. I wouldn’t do this to her.

Tom Broecker: Why the pouch? Why not wear a cummerbund and do the whole matador thing? But then it’s like, is she wearing a costume? Sometimes when you’re going from runway to reality, it doesn’t translate.

Dino Dinco: I think the shoes are interesting for a flamenco dance teacher, but man, those balls.

HELENA BONHAM CARTER IN DEBORAH MILNER AT THE 2006 OSCARS

Alicia Lawhon: Unless you’re Bjork, it’s hard to pull off conceptual, but the idea of the gown is pretty. I love how it falls off the shoulders. I could rework this outfit, starting with that hemline that looks like it’s tucked into her knee-highs.

Tom Broecker: She has gorgeous shoulders and a nice cleavage, but imagine what that dress would look like in black matte velvet? She would look like the John Singer Sargent painting.

Dino Dinco: Is that Texan hair? It’s not Merchant Ivory, that’s for sure.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Scene News from Variety

Loading