Review: ‘The Foreign Eye’

With amusement and a hint of anger, leading Brazilian helmer Lucia Murat's "The Foreign Eye" looks at what the former journalist sees as false depictions of her home country in the movies. Doc's thesis is that outside filmmakers paint Brazil as a land of bikinis, bossa nova and exotic locales without bothering to learn about this vast, complex South American nation.

With amusement and a hint of anger, leading Brazilian helmer Lucia Murat’s “The Foreign Eye” looks at what the former journalist sees as false depictions of her home country in the movies. Doc’s thesis is that outside filmmakers paint Brazil as a land of bikinis, bossa nova and exotic locales without bothering to learn about this vast, complex South American nation. This exceptional fest doc deserves to travel beyond specialized Latino confabs, though commercial prospects are tied to the nettlesome task of clearing rights on numerous film clips.

Murat tracks down major film personalities involved in memorable and less well-known movies set in Brazil, including three key figures behind the light farce “Blame It on Rio” — writer Larry Gelbart (in fine form), co-writer Charlie Peters and star Michael Caine, who looks disarmed and a tad abashed by Murat’s tough questions.

Murat isn’t playing “gotcha” with movie stars, although she captures both Jon Voight and Hope Davis in stunned moments of realization that films they were in (he in “Anaconda,” she in “Next Stop, Wonderland”) involved egregious cultural goofs regarding Brazil. When Davis learns that, contrary to dialogue in “Wonderland,” there’s no beach in Sao Paolo, she reddens several shades.

Murat manages to get soft-core helmer Zalman King (“Wild Orchid”) and Gelbart to agree that there’s arrogance behind delivering phony national images on a mass-market basis.

Murat expands her theme beyond Hollywood movies to include telling interviews with such vet Gallic helmers as Philippe de Broca (“That Man From Rio”), Gerard Lauzier (“T’empeche tout les monde de dormir”) and Eduoard Luntz (“Hung Up”), as well as Swedish producer Bo Jonsson. All convey various aspects of a certain colonialist bias toward Latin American “exoticism” that seems to persist to this day.

Vid work is simple and basic, while some archival clips (including a fabulous item documenting Orson Welles making his sensitive look at Brazil, “It’s All True”) are extraordinary in this smart, compact doc.

The Foreign Eye

Brazil

Production

A Taiga Filmes & Video/Limite/Okeanos production. Produced by Dudu Miranda, Lucia Murat, Luis Vidal, Paula Abou-Jaoude. Executive producers, Vidal, Abou-Jaoude. Directed by Lucia Murat. Written by Murat, Tunico Amancio.

Crew

Camera (color, DV), Dudu Miranda; editor, Julia Murat; music, Ze Paulo Becker CQ; sound (Dolby Digital), Simone Petrilho. Reviewed at Los Angeles Latino Film Festival, Oct. 14, 2006. (Also in Rio, Sao Paolo film festivals.) Running time: 70 MIN.

With

Michael Caine, Jon Voight, Tony Plana, Larry Gelbart, Charlie Peters, David Weisman, Robert Ellis Miller, Philippe de Broca, Greydon Clark, Hope Davis, Zalman King, Edouard Luntz, Gerard Lauzier, Philippe Clair, Bo Jonsson. CQ (English, Portuguese, French, Spanish dialogue)
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety

Loading