Sam’s Lake

"Sam's Lake," a by-the-numbers rehash of countless killer-in-the woods pics, fails to reinvigorate the genre despite a surprise twist nearly three-quarters in. Vidstores may do OK with the horror crowd, but theatrical prospects are dire.

With:
With: Fay Masterson, Sandrine Holt, William Gregory Lee, Stephen Bishop, Salvatore Antonio, Megan Fahlenbock, Peter Beks, Richard Foster, Jess McCormick, Robert William Smith, Serra Stewart, Kindred Carter, Kaitlyne Dunne.

“Sam’s Lake,” a by-the-numbers rehash of countless killer-in-the woods pics, fails to reinvigorate the genre despite a surprise twist nearly three-quarters in. Shot in 18 days in the autumnal splendor of British Columbia, Andrew Christopher Erin’s debut feature grew out of a story he heard about a deranged kid who murdered his family, but despite this kernel of truth, the plot still feels like tired campfire material. Vidstores may do OK with the horror crowd, but theatrical prospects are dire.

On the anniversary of her father’s death in a hunting accident, Sam (Fay Masterson) gathers a group of close friends for moral support and a weekend away at the family cottage. Things turn creepy when they stop for supplies near the house, and the store clerk — the usual inbred misfit — tells them, “These parts ain’t safe this time of year.”

Everyone laughs it off, although little cornhusk dolls around town do spook them a little. Still, the lake is beautiful, and Sam’s infectious pleasure in the natural surroundings makes rural inconvenience part of the fun. The jolly party increases when Sam’s old friend Jesse (William Gregory Lee) comes by, instantly charming Kate (“24’s” Sandrine Holt) with his reticent manner and studly blond looks.

During the inevitable campfire scarefest, Sam tells about a local haunted house where, years earlier, a disturbed teen returned from the loony bin and slaughtered his family. She and Jesse promise the group a good old fright, and off they go to the rundown place, where unexplained noises send everyone screaming back to the car — but not before Franklin (Stephen Bishop) pulls an old diary out of the fireplace, and they begin to read the killer’s entries.

To Erin’s credit, the ensuing bloodbath is low on outright gore, aiming for more heart-pounding tension, but the dialogue is older than the hills and set-ups are equally hoary. Even the overused trick of creating suspense by offering fleeting glimpses of a fast-moving figure in the immediate foreground fails to excite the senses.

The cast is a mixed bunch, although Masterson offers glimpses of intelligence considerably beyond her material. The teen girl crowd will enjoy the sight of a bare-chested Lee, who obligingly keeps his shirt off for the last half hour, looking for all the world like a Tarzan of the deciduous forest.

Sharp viewers will be kept guessing where the light sources come from in the supposedly undeveloped woods. Not surprisingly, vet composer Gary Chang’s incidental music is big on eerie sounds underlining even the most innocuous of actions.

Sam's Lake

South Korea-U.S.-Canada

Production: A Mirovision (South Korea), Maverick Films (U.S.) presentation of a Knick Knack (U.S.), .40 Caliber (U.S.), One Eye Open (Canada) production. (International sales, Mirovision, Seoul; U.S. sales, William Morris Independent, Beverly Hills.) Produced by Amy Green, Cassie Yoo, Julian Chang Zolkin, E. Thompson. Executive producers, Jason Chae, Mark Morgan, Guy Oseary, Milton Kim. Co-producer, Edy Enriquez. Directed, written by Andrew Christopher Erin.

Crew: Camera (color), David A. Armstrong; editor, Miklos Wright; music, Gary Chang; production designer, Paul McCulloch; art directors, Andrew King, Ernie Tomlinson; costume designer, Patricia Louise Hargreaves; sound (Dolby Digital), John Boyle, Jerry Gilbert; stunt coordinator, Jodi Stecyk; line producer, Sherry Lynn King; associate producers, Eric M. Klein, Barbara Jane Chomos; assistant director, Matthias Mellinghaus. Reviewed at Tribeca Film Festival (Midnight), May 2, 2006. Running time: 86 MIN.

With: With: Fay Masterson, Sandrine Holt, William Gregory Lee, Stephen Bishop, Salvatore Antonio, Megan Fahlenbock, Peter Beks, Richard Foster, Jess McCormick, Robert William Smith, Serra Stewart, Kindred Carter, Kaitlyne Dunne.

More Film

  • American Genre Film Archive Partnering With

    Film News Roundup: American Genre Film Archive Partners With Shaw Brothers (EXCLUSIVE)

    “Sam’s Lake,” a by-the-numbers rehash of countless killer-in-the woods pics, fails to reinvigorate the genre despite a surprise twist nearly three-quarters in. Shot in 18 days in the autumnal splendor of British Columbia, Andrew Christopher Erin’s debut feature grew out of a story he heard about a deranged kid who murdered his family, but despite […]

  • Andrea Riseborough on Pay Equity, Hollywood

    Why Andrea Riseborough Could Be the Breakout Star of Sundance

    “Sam’s Lake,” a by-the-numbers rehash of countless killer-in-the woods pics, fails to reinvigorate the genre despite a surprise twist nearly three-quarters in. Shot in 18 days in the autumnal splendor of British Columbia, Andrew Christopher Erin’s debut feature grew out of a story he heard about a deranged kid who murdered his family, but despite […]

  • William Friedkin’s ‘The Devil and Father

    William Friedkin's Exorcism Documentary 'The Devil and Father Amorth' Acquired by Orchard

    “Sam’s Lake,” a by-the-numbers rehash of countless killer-in-the woods pics, fails to reinvigorate the genre despite a surprise twist nearly three-quarters in. Shot in 18 days in the autumnal splendor of British Columbia, Andrew Christopher Erin’s debut feature grew out of a story he heard about a deranged kid who murdered his family, but despite […]

  • The Mummy

    U.S. Movie Ticket Sales Plunged 6% in 2017, Thanks to Lousy Summer

    “Sam’s Lake,” a by-the-numbers rehash of countless killer-in-the woods pics, fails to reinvigorate the genre despite a surprise twist nearly three-quarters in. Shot in 18 days in the autumnal splendor of British Columbia, Andrew Christopher Erin’s debut feature grew out of a story he heard about a deranged kid who murdered his family, but despite […]

  • Lea Thompson's 'Year of Spectacular Men'

    Lea Thompson's Directorial Debut 'Year of Spectacular Men' Acquired by MarVista Entertainment

    “Sam’s Lake,” a by-the-numbers rehash of countless killer-in-the woods pics, fails to reinvigorate the genre despite a surprise twist nearly three-quarters in. Shot in 18 days in the autumnal splendor of British Columbia, Andrew Christopher Erin’s debut feature grew out of a story he heard about a deranged kid who murdered his family, but despite […]

  • santa barbara film festival arlington theater

    Santa Barbara Film Festival to Open as Planned in Wake of Montecito Mudslides

    “Sam’s Lake,” a by-the-numbers rehash of countless killer-in-the woods pics, fails to reinvigorate the genre despite a surprise twist nearly three-quarters in. Shot in 18 days in the autumnal splendor of British Columbia, Andrew Christopher Erin’s debut feature grew out of a story he heard about a deranged kid who murdered his family, but despite […]

  • Ella Rumpf Avez Brothers

    Variety Unveils 10 Europeans to Watch for 2018

    “Sam’s Lake,” a by-the-numbers rehash of countless killer-in-the woods pics, fails to reinvigorate the genre despite a surprise twist nearly three-quarters in. Shot in 18 days in the autumnal splendor of British Columbia, Andrew Christopher Erin’s debut feature grew out of a story he heard about a deranged kid who murdered his family, but despite […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content