You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Forgiveness

"Forgiveness" requires a good bit of titular emotion from any viewer expecting a measured view of Arab-Israeli relations. Specialty fests and ancillary afterlife may pardon this well-intentioned but elaborate meller, though distribs are likely to forget it in short order.

Cast:
With: Itay Tiran, Clara Khoury, Moni Moshonov, Makram J, Khoury, Michael Sarne, Tamara Mansour, Ruba Blal, Idit Teperson, Omer Barnea, Greg Lucas. (English, Hebrew, Arabic dialogue.)

An overcooked ragout of genre elements — perfunctory supernatural thriller, idealistic Middle East political drama and a few slick, fragmentary dance numbers, “Forgiveness” requires a good bit of titular emotion from any viewer expecting a measured view of Arab-Israeli relations. Specialty fests and ancillary afterlife may pardon this well-intentioned but elaborate meller, though distribs are likely to forget it in short order.

Victim of an unknown trauma while serving in the Israeli army to escape his successful musician father (Michael Sarne), American Jew  David Adler (Itay Tiran) is under the care of earnest doctor Isaac Shemesh (Makram J. Khoury) in a mental institution. But, the patients — elderly Holocaust survivors and recuperating young soldiers — seem to be getting worse instead of better.

Apparently unbeknownst to all save one agitated inmate (Moni Moshonov), called “Muselmann” after the German and Jewish term for the weakest people in Auschwitz, the facility was built on the site of a Palestinian village where more than 100 residents were killed by Israeli troops in 1948. While this may or may not explain the patients’ deteriorating behavior, medico has reluctantly begun doling out an experimental anti-memory drug.

Narrative then sprints both forward and back, revealing the source of David’s anguish while on patrol as well as his post-service romance in New York with Palestinian singer Lila (Clara Khoury). When the veteran ditches his meds, the distant and recent past converge on the present.

Any one of these plot strands might have made an interesting film. Woven together they’re a misshapen tapestry of conflicting emotions, held together by the spooky presence of a mysterious young girl (Tamara Mansour).

All tension is disrupted, however, by brief musical interludes, most egregious of which unfolds on an Israeli dance floor fitted with a “Flashdance”-like shower head.

Performances have a tangible self-consciousness, with only Khoury, luminously betrothed in “Rana’s Wedding” and “The Syrian Bride,” looking comfortable as an assertive divorcee and single mom.

Tech credits are crisp. Helmer Udi Aloni as much as admitted to world premiere Berlin fest aud he had little interest in tying up loose plot threads, deflecting political inquiries in favor of an invocation suggesting love is all we need.

That and a good script editor.

Forgiveness

Israel-U.S.

Production: A Metro Communications (Tel Aviv)/Elevation Filmworks (New York) production. Produced by David Silber, Lemore Syvan, Udi Aloni. Executive producers, Moshe Edery, Leon Edery, Micky Rabinovitz, Andre Malignac, Sigal Primor. Directed by Udi Aloni. Screenplay, Aloni, Paul Hond, from the book by Aloni.

Crew: Camera (color, HD-to-35mm), Amnon Zalait; editor, Galia Gill Moors; music, Tamir Muskat; production designers, Kuly Sander, Tommaso Ortino; costume designers, Danny Bar Shay, Amanda Ford; sound (Dolby SRD), Danny Shitrit, Teferra Mckenzie; sound designer, Chen Harpaz; choreographer, Ohad Naharin; associate producer, Sarah Kamens;  assistant directors, Avichai Henig, Shimon Azulay. Reviewed at Berlin Film Festival (Panorama), Feb. 11, 2006. Running time: 97 MIN.

With: With: Itay Tiran, Clara Khoury, Moni Moshonov, Makram J, Khoury, Michael Sarne, Tamara Mansour, Ruba Blal, Idit Teperson, Omer Barnea, Greg Lucas. (English, Hebrew, Arabic dialogue.)

More Film

  • Argentinean Actress Norma Aleandro Famous For

    Morelia: Mexico’s Fénix Ibero-American Film Awards Announces Winners and Nominees

    An overcooked ragout of genre elements — perfunctory supernatural thriller, idealistic Middle East political drama and a few slick, fragmentary dance numbers, “Forgiveness” requires a good bit of titular emotion from any viewer expecting a measured view of Arab-Israeli relations. Specialty fests and ancillary afterlife may pardon this well-intentioned but elaborate meller, though distribs are […]

  • Lorenzo VigasOswaldo Vigas documentary and exhibition,

    Morelia: ‘From Afar’s’ Lorenzo Vigas Discusses Documenting His Family in ‘The Orchid Seller’

    An overcooked ragout of genre elements — perfunctory supernatural thriller, idealistic Middle East political drama and a few slick, fragmentary dance numbers, “Forgiveness” requires a good bit of titular emotion from any viewer expecting a measured view of Arab-Israeli relations. Specialty fests and ancillary afterlife may pardon this well-intentioned but elaborate meller, though distribs are […]

  • Japan Box Office: 'Mixed Doubles' Makes

    Japan Box Office: ‘Mixed Doubles’ Opens at Number One

    An overcooked ragout of genre elements — perfunctory supernatural thriller, idealistic Middle East political drama and a few slick, fragmentary dance numbers, “Forgiveness” requires a good bit of titular emotion from any viewer expecting a measured view of Arab-Israeli relations. Specialty fests and ancillary afterlife may pardon this well-intentioned but elaborate meller, though distribs are […]

  • Antalya Festival: Ender Özkahraman on ‘Ugly

    Antalya Festival: Ender Özkahraman on ‘Ugly Duckling,’ Plastic Surgery in the Kurdish Community

    An overcooked ragout of genre elements — perfunctory supernatural thriller, idealistic Middle East political drama and a few slick, fragmentary dance numbers, “Forgiveness” requires a good bit of titular emotion from any viewer expecting a measured view of Arab-Israeli relations. Specialty fests and ancillary afterlife may pardon this well-intentioned but elaborate meller, though distribs are […]

  • Christopher Walken on ‘King of New

    Antalya Festival: A Modest Christopher Walken Talks ‘King of New York,’ His Own Acting Style, and Michael Cimino

    An overcooked ragout of genre elements — perfunctory supernatural thriller, idealistic Middle East political drama and a few slick, fragmentary dance numbers, “Forgiveness” requires a good bit of titular emotion from any viewer expecting a measured view of Arab-Israeli relations. Specialty fests and ancillary afterlife may pardon this well-intentioned but elaborate meller, though distribs are […]

  • Ikebukuro Move Puts Tokyo Market in

    Ikebukuro Move Puts Tokyo Market in Growth Mode, says Yasushi Shiina

    An overcooked ragout of genre elements — perfunctory supernatural thriller, idealistic Middle East political drama and a few slick, fragmentary dance numbers, “Forgiveness” requires a good bit of titular emotion from any viewer expecting a measured view of Arab-Israeli relations. Specialty fests and ancillary afterlife may pardon this well-intentioned but elaborate meller, though distribs are […]

  • Turkish Cinema: The New Generation -

    Turkish Cinema: The New Generation - Tolga Karacelik, Director 'Butterflies'

    An overcooked ragout of genre elements — perfunctory supernatural thriller, idealistic Middle East political drama and a few slick, fragmentary dance numbers, “Forgiveness” requires a good bit of titular emotion from any viewer expecting a measured view of Arab-Israeli relations. Specialty fests and ancillary afterlife may pardon this well-intentioned but elaborate meller, though distribs are […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content