Review: ‘Forbidden to Forbid’

Excitingly unpredictable drama about a trio of Rio college friends who get involved in a dangerous criminal world when they help a young street kid, "Forbidden to Forbid" cannily exposes police corruption and murder in the context of a richly textured, engrossing character study. Fest awards could open the door to arthouse sales.

Excitingly unpredictable drama about a trio of Rio college friends — one a girl both boys are in love with — who get involved in a dangerous criminal world when they help a young street kid, “Forbidden to Forbid” cannily exposes police corruption and murder in the context of a richly textured, engrossing character study. Inventive second feature by Jorge Duran (“A cor do seu destino”) is the kind of cool, irreverent fare one expects of top Brazilian offerings. Young auds should have no trouble getting on its wavelength, while fest awards could open the door to arthouse sales.

Pic won the Films in Progress prize at San Sebastian last year. Duran, a Chilean who lives in Brazil, also won best director at Chile’s Valdivia meet this month.

Paulo (Caio Blat) is a med student whose anarchic motto is “forbidden to forbid.” He dulls his sharp brain with recreational drugs, giving rise to a wild opening sequence in which he goes to work at the hospital totally stoned. Still, he’s able to brilliantly answer his prof’s question about what is ailing the housemaid Rosalina (Edyr Duqui) — leukemia.

Meanwhile, Paulo’s best friend Leon (Alexandre Rodrigues), a politically committed sociology student doing a study on slum kids, is high on his romance with architecture student Leticia (Maria Flor). A brief rooftop sex scene illustrates their attraction to each other. But when she moves in with the two boys, Leticia becomes Paulo’s forbidden object of desire.

Duran and Dani Patarra’s script is cleverly layered with no signs of forcing. Paulo’s increasing closeness to the dying Rosalina brings him into contact with Rio’s slums, where he discovers one of her sons, a CD street vendor, has been murdered by the police. Her younger son, an eyewitness, is targeted for death.

When they decide to help the boy, the trio of friends ends up in a nightmare.

Cast is finely selected, with standouts Blat and Rodrigues relaxed and mature as the boys. So different from each other and yet so closely bonded, they introduce a note of optimism into a future Brazil that otherwise looks pretty frightening. Flor is bright and believable as the girl.

This low-budgeter was shot with more dash than cash. Luis Abramo’s cinematography is stark and striking, particularly when he photographs the awe-inspiring buildings that Le Corbusier and other modern architects built in Brazil. Often, the reverse shot is a sea of slums. Film’s symbolic finale, which resolves very little and leaves the future open, is lensed amid the ruins of a piece of modern architecture being eaten up by a jungle.

Forbidden to Forbid

Brazil

Production

An El Desierto Filmes production in association with Ceneca Producciones, A&A Producoes, Mediapro. (International sales: Americine, Buenos Aires.) Produced by Suzana Amado. Directed by Jorge Duran. Screenplay, Duran, Dani Patarra.

Crew

Camera (color), Luis Abramo; editor, Pedro Duran; production designer, Jose Joaquim Salles; costume designers, Joana Ribas, Ana Catanhede; sound (Dolby Digital), Heron Alencar. Reviewed at San Sebastian Film Festival (Zabaltegi), Sept. 22, 2006. (Also in Valdivia Film Festival.) Running time: 103 MIN.

With

Paulo - Caio Blat Leticia - Maria Flor Leon - Alexandre Rodrigues Rosalina - Edyr Duqui
With: Luciano Vidigal, Raquel Padras, Adriano Jesus.
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety

Loading