Review: ‘Amnesia: The James Brighton Enigma’

Inspired by real events, drama "Amnesia: The James Brighton Enigma" ekes middling results from a fascinating storyline. Tale of a young gay man trying to reconstruct his identity after being left naked and beaten in a Montreal parking lot offers an intriguing mystery.

Inspired by real events, drama “Amnesia: The James Brighton Enigma” ekes middling results from a fascinating storyline. Tale of a young gay man trying to reconstruct his identity after being left naked and beaten in a Montreal parking lot offers an intriguing mystery. But this latest feature from writer-helmer Denis Langlois (“L’Escorte”) lacks the directorial vision or arresting lead turn that would lift it above telepic-level adequacy. Bilingual French-English pic nonetheless should secure decent broadcast sales and DVD distribution in a number of territories.

Handsome, doleful-eyed, mid-20s protag (Dusan Dukic) is seen held at knifepoint by young louts in a speeding car. He is stripped, pummeled and left unconscious.

Disoriented, he awakes to find clothes scattered nearby, and istaken by police to a hospital where he spends more than a month in a psych ward under the care of a sympathetic doctor (Louise Laprade). Diagnosed with disassociative amnesia, he remembers nothing of his prior life. A few dim apparent recalls, including his name, James Brighton, lead authorities nowhere in identifying him.

“James” now decides he was — or at least now is — gay, and a local community org gets him taken in by linguistics professor Felix (Norman Helms). Felix is romantically attracted by the young man’s vulnerability. The ease with which “James” slips into being a darling of the Montreal gay club scene leads some to suspect he’s no amnesiac victim but an impostor desiring a fresh start.

Belying that negative view is James’ eagerness to be media-interviewed in hopes of being recognized by anyone who knows him. Yet worst suspicions seem confirmed when, after his story is broadcast on a U.S. tabloid-TV show, he is identified — as one Matthew Honeycutt from Tennessee, where he’s wanted for arrest on petty charges. Protag “goes home,” even though he says he still doesn’t recognize hometown or relatives, both knee-deep in Pentecostal Church culture. He does immediately remember the family dog — implying its unconditional love might lay in stark contrast to every other formative relationship.

Increasing flashback nightmares suggest psychiatric instability underlined by a disapproving religious community and tripped into breakdown by homophobic violence. But the unlikelihood that such violence brought no legal consequence robs the tentatively upbeat fade of credibility.

Memory-flashes aside, the chronologically ordered tale is framed by the present-tense inquiry of Montreal criminologist-in-training Sylvie (Karyne Lemieux), who’s decided to write her thesis paper about the “James Brighton” case. This device is OK, but pic needs a stronger cinematic style to convey the protag’s ambiguities. Instead, the film (looking a tad dark and soft in 35mm transfer) is serviceable, but pedestrian.

Puppyish Yugo-born Canadian lead Dukic’s naif performance inadvertently flags “James” as a possible liar before — and after — we should suspect him of being one. Support perfs are solid, with Steven Turpin (who played an amnesiac in 2003 Canuck indie “Saved by the Belles”) vivid in a key late support role.

Production values are pro, though the package could have used more imagination. Closing title updates the real-life amnesiac’s situation.

Amnesia: The James Brighton Enigma



A K-Films Amerique presentation of a Les Prods. Castor & Pollux production in association with Sodec, Telefilm Canada and Astral Television. Produced by Bertrand Lachance, Denis Langlois. Directed by Denis Langlois. Screenplay, Langlois, Bertrand Lachance.


Camera (color, DVC-Pro 50-to-35mm), Larry Lynn; editor, Langlois; music, Peter Xirogiannis; production designer, Genevieve Blais; costume designer, Corinne Montpetit; sound (Dolby Dig), Denis Saindon. Reviewed at San Francisco Lesbian & Gay Film Festival, June 22, 2006. Running time: 90 MIN.


Dusan Dukic, Karyne Lemieux, Norman Helms, Louise Laprade, L. Kalo Gow, Bruce Ramsay, Eric Cabana, Steven Turpin. (English, French dialogue)
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety