Acad’s new tune for song

New rules are introduced for Oscar's music category

And the award for most confusing new rules goes to … the song category.

The Academy holds a “bake-off” (though it doesn’t like to call it that) in which 40 or so songs are shown in three-minute clips. Everyone in the music branch is invited, though not everyone shows up. The two screenings were both held in L.A. so out-of-towners are out of luck.

Music members then rate each song on a scale of 6-10. To get nominated, a song has to score 8.25 or higher. Or, as the Acad puts it in a release, the change in rules imposes “a minimum required scoring average.”

This year, three songs qualified. Other rules include the fact that a song cannot be run under dialogue (it has to be “clearly audible, intelligible, substantive rendition” of the song) and a song is eligible if it’s the first song in the end credits, but not an end-credit song after that.

If more than five films score more than 8.25, the noms go to the five highest. If none hits that lofty peak, it goes to the three highest scorers.

More Film

  • Mary Elizabeth Winstead to Co-Star With

    Mary Elizabeth Winstead to Co-Star With Will Smith in Skydance's 'Gemini Man'

    And the award for most confusing new rules goes to … the song category. The Academy holds a “bake-off” (though it doesn’t like to call it that) in which 40 or so songs are shown in three-minute clips. Everyone in the music branch is invited, though not everyone shows up. The two screenings were both […]

  • Wide Release on Christian Bale's 'Hostiles'

    Film News Roundup: Wide Release on Christian Bale's 'Hostiles' Moved Back a Week

    And the award for most confusing new rules goes to … the song category. The Academy holds a “bake-off” (though it doesn’t like to call it that) in which 40 or so songs are shown in three-minute clips. Everyone in the music branch is invited, though not everyone shows up. The two screenings were both […]

  • Sundance Womens March

    Sundance: How Will Festival Tackle #MeToo, Political Turmoil, and More?

    And the award for most confusing new rules goes to … the song category. The Academy holds a “bake-off” (though it doesn’t like to call it that) in which 40 or so songs are shown in three-minute clips. Everyone in the music branch is invited, though not everyone shows up. The two screenings were both […]

  • 'Maktub' Review: Palm Springs Film Festival

    Film Review: 'Maktub'

    And the award for most confusing new rules goes to … the song category. The Academy holds a “bake-off” (though it doesn’t like to call it that) in which 40 or so songs are shown in three-minute clips. Everyone in the music branch is invited, though not everyone shows up. The two screenings were both […]

  • DEADPOOL

    MPAA: Film, TV Industry Paid Out $49 Billion in 2016

    And the award for most confusing new rules goes to … the song category. The Academy holds a “bake-off” (though it doesn’t like to call it that) in which 40 or so songs are shown in three-minute clips. Everyone in the music branch is invited, though not everyone shows up. The two screenings were both […]

  • Sophie Watts

    Sophie Watts Steps Down as STX President

    And the award for most confusing new rules goes to … the song category. The Academy holds a “bake-off” (though it doesn’t like to call it that) in which 40 or so songs are shown in three-minute clips. Everyone in the music branch is invited, though not everyone shows up. The two screenings were both […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content