The Hawk Is Dying

Writer-director Julian Goldberger squanders the resources of a proven producing team and talented actors in his murkily metaphorical sophomore feature, "The Hawk Is Dying." Based on Harry Crews' novel, this self-conscious exercise in narrative obfuscation likely will have its first and last significant exposure at Sundance.

With:
With: Paul Giamatti, Michelle Williams, Michael Pitt, Rusty Schwimmer, Robert Wisdom, Ann Wedgeworth.

Writer-director Julian Goldberger, whose 1999 debut, “Trans,” drew a coterie of admirers with its meditative approach and rigorous non-aesthetic, squanders the resources of a proven producing team and talented actors in his murkily metaphorical sophomore feature, “The Hawk Is Dying.” Based on Harry Crews’ novel about a dirt-poor Central Florida man touched by tragedy who refuses to join his family in the traditional grieving process, this self-conscious exercise in narrative obfuscation likely will have its first and last significant exposure at Sundance, hitting the ultra-arty end of the fest trail thereafter.

Performers capable of exquisite work elsewhere are undirected here. Paul Giamatti, who plays a man channeling his guilt into a sanity-testing obsession with falconry following the freak drowning of his mentally challenged nephew (Michael Pitt), indulges in actorish explosions of emotional volatility. Meanwhile, Michelle Williams, as a stoner psych student, embodies the film’s overriding dramatic inertia. Crews (who lost his own child in a drowning) is known for his trenchantly honest prose, which here is translated by Goldberger with such affected rawness and technical austerity that the pain of the characters is merely distancing. Already gasping for breath in its opening scenes, pic takes two bleak, unyielding hours to finally expire.

The Hawk Is Dying

Production: A Big Heart Pictures presentation in association with Exile Prods. of an Antidote Films production in association with This Is That, Next Wednesday. Produced by Jeff Levy-Hinte, Mary Jane Skalski. Executive producers, Ted Hope, Corbin Day, Jeanne Levy-Hinte. Co-producer, Joshua Zeman. Directed, written by Julian Goldberger, based on the novel by Harry Crews.

Crew: Camera (color), Bobby Bukowski; editor, Affonso Goncalves; music, Goldberger; production designer, Judy Becker; set decorator, Vera Mills; costume designer, April Napier. Reviewed at Sundance Film Festival (competing), Jan. 21, 2006. (Also in Cannes Film Festival -- Directors Fortnight.) Running time: 112 MIN.

With: With: Paul Giamatti, Michelle Williams, Michael Pitt, Rusty Schwimmer, Robert Wisdom, Ann Wedgeworth.

More Film

  • Damsel Sundance Film Festival

    Sundance Film Review: 'Damsel'

    Writer-director Julian Goldberger, whose 1999 debut, “Trans,” drew a coterie of admirers with its meditative approach and rigorous non-aesthetic, squanders the resources of a proven producing team and talented actors in his murkily metaphorical sophomore feature, “The Hawk Is Dying.” Based on Harry Crews’ novel about a dirt-poor Central Florida man touched by tragedy who […]

  • 'Get Out,' 'Dunkirk' Back In Theaters

    'Get Out,' 'Dunkirk' to Return to Movie Theaters Following Oscar Nominations

    Writer-director Julian Goldberger, whose 1999 debut, “Trans,” drew a coterie of admirers with its meditative approach and rigorous non-aesthetic, squanders the resources of a proven producing team and talented actors in his murkily metaphorical sophomore feature, “The Hawk Is Dying.” Based on Harry Crews’ novel about a dirt-poor Central Florida man touched by tragedy who […]

  • Sundance Film Festival Placeholder

    A&E, Sundance Institute Partner on Documentary Film Grants (EXCLUSIVE)

    Writer-director Julian Goldberger, whose 1999 debut, “Trans,” drew a coterie of admirers with its meditative approach and rigorous non-aesthetic, squanders the resources of a proven producing team and talented actors in his murkily metaphorical sophomore feature, “The Hawk Is Dying.” Based on Harry Crews’ novel about a dirt-poor Central Florida man touched by tragedy who […]

  • Anne Hathaway Live Fast Die Hot

    Anne Hathaway's 'Barbie' Moved Back Two Years to 2020

    Writer-director Julian Goldberger, whose 1999 debut, “Trans,” drew a coterie of admirers with its meditative approach and rigorous non-aesthetic, squanders the resources of a proven producing team and talented actors in his murkily metaphorical sophomore feature, “The Hawk Is Dying.” Based on Harry Crews’ novel about a dirt-poor Central Florida man touched by tragedy who […]

  • Who is Sufjan Stevens? Oscars Introduce

    Who Is Oscar Best Song Nominee Sufjan Stevens, Beloved by Indie-Rock Fans and Music Supervisors?

    Writer-director Julian Goldberger, whose 1999 debut, “Trans,” drew a coterie of admirers with its meditative approach and rigorous non-aesthetic, squanders the resources of a proven producing team and talented actors in his murkily metaphorical sophomore feature, “The Hawk Is Dying.” Based on Harry Crews’ novel about a dirt-poor Central Florida man touched by tragedy who […]

  • Bellucci, Belmondo Announced As Lumière Award

    Monica Bellucci, Jean-Paul Belmondo Announced as Guests of Honor at France's Lumière Awards

    Writer-director Julian Goldberger, whose 1999 debut, “Trans,” drew a coterie of admirers with its meditative approach and rigorous non-aesthetic, squanders the resources of a proven producing team and talented actors in his murkily metaphorical sophomore feature, “The Hawk Is Dying.” Based on Harry Crews’ novel about a dirt-poor Central Florida man touched by tragedy who […]

  • 'Death of Stalin' Banned in Russia

    Russia Bans Dark Comedy 'The Death of Stalin'

    Writer-director Julian Goldberger, whose 1999 debut, “Trans,” drew a coterie of admirers with its meditative approach and rigorous non-aesthetic, squanders the resources of a proven producing team and talented actors in his murkily metaphorical sophomore feature, “The Hawk Is Dying.” Based on Harry Crews’ novel about a dirt-poor Central Florida man touched by tragedy who […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content