Review: ‘Silk’

A ghost flick without one decent scare, "Silk" is way too smooth for its own good. The tale of a bunch of scientists who manage to capture a tyke ghost boasts impressive f/x but brings nothing new to the table. Pic seemed a strange choice for a slot in Cannes' Official Selection, and looks to segue rapidly to ancillary, especially in the West.

An Asian ghost flick without one decent scare in two hours, “Silk” is way too smooth for its own good. Reportedly, at $6.2 million, the most expensive locally-funded movie ever made in Taiwan, tale of a bunch of scientists who manage to capture a tyke ghost boasts impressive f/x but brings nothing new to the genre table. Given the continuing strength of the Asian scare industry, pic seemed a strange choice for a slot in Cannes’ Official Selection, and looks to segue rapidly to ancillary, especially in the West.

Writer-director Su Chao-pin sprung to attention four years ago with the cheeky comedy “Better Than Sex,” but the sophomore curse strikes with a vengeance in “Silk.” Over-complicated script, which tries to mix science, ghost cliches and protags’ personal problems in a single pot, starts OK but gradually runs out of steam after the first 40 minutes.

Pic suffers from all of the same problems that afflicted earlier Taiwanese psycho-thriller, “Double Vision” (2002), which Su scripted: fuzzy writing, lack of on-screen chemistry between usually reliable thesps, and no real imagination beyond the f/x. Though made on a fraction of the “Silk” budget, there’s more creepiness and invention per foot of film in last year’s Taiwanese spookfest “The Heirloom.”

A team of scientists, led by the crippled Hashimoto (Yosuke Eguchi), have discovered a boy ghost (Chen Kuan-po) in a rundown Taipei apartment block and, using an anti-gravitational device called the Menger Sponge — a kind of Rubik’s Cube with a mind of its own — have trapped it in a room-cum-lab.

To help solve the mystery of who the kid is, Hashimoto recruits local police sharpshooter Ye Chi-tung (Chang Chen), who has exceptional eyesight and also happens to lip-read.

A smidgeon of character conflict is generated early on as Hashimoto’s colleague, Su Yuen (Barbie Hsu, barbed), who also fancies the Japanese cripple, resents Ye being hired. When she, in the pic’s best sequence, ends up dead after trying to smuggle the ghost out for her own purposes, a lot of air goes out of the film’s balloon.

With Su out of the way, Ye is free to action his plan of releasing and following the ghost — which he can see by spraying an aerosol version of the Menger Sponge on his eyes. (Right.) The journey subsequently touches on Ye’s troubled personal past as well as impacting his present relationship with flower-shop cutie Du Jia-wei (Karena Lam).

One of the best of Hong Kong’s younger generation of actresses, Lam is wasted in a blah role, and ditto Taiwanese star Chen Po-lin in a support as one of Hashimoto’s assistants. Chang is all icy, uninvolving control as Ye and Japanese thesp Eguchi scowls under heavy make-up.

The largely Hong Kong tech team produce a smooth package, led by Arthur Wong’s lensing (all cold colors) and composer Peter Kam’s by-the-yard atmospherics. Visual effects, by H.K.’s Menfond, and special make-up effects, by Australia’s MEG, are tip-top. But it’s all a lot of tech talent in service of very little.




A CMC Entertainment presentation of a Unit 9 pictures production. (International sales: CMC, Taipei, Taiwan.) Produced by Tu Min. Executive producers, Huang Chin-wen, Jimmy Huang. Directed, written by Su Chao-pin.


Camera (color, Panavision widescreen), Arthur Wong; editor, Cheung Ka-fai; music, Peter Kam; production designer, Yohei Taneda; art director, Chen Po-jen; costume designer, Lee Pik-kwan; sound (Dolby Digital), Soundfirm; visual effects, Menfond Electronic Art & Computer Design Co.; visual effects supervisor, Foo Sing-choong; visual effects consultants, Victor Wong, Eddy Wong; action choreographer, Tung Wai; special make-up effects, Paul Katte, Nick Nicolaou; associate producers, Yeh Ju-feng, David Tang; assistant directors, An Je-yi, Chen Guan-ming. Reviewed at Cannes Film Festival (Midnight Screening, non-competing), May 24, 2006. Running time: 117 MIN.


With: Chang Chen, Yosuke Eguchi, Karena Lam, Barbie Su, Chen Po-lin, Chang Chun-ning, Fang Wen, Chen Kuan-po. (Mandarin, Japanese, English, Hokkien dialogue)
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Biz News from Variety