You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Looking For The Lost Voice

Director-writer Tzipi Trope's well intentioned docu, "Looking for the Lost Voice," unfortunately proves that it takes more than a family's grief and a plea for peace to make a compelling film. This effort, based on the death of an Israeli army officer and punk band vocalist in a suicide bombing, won't draw many interested viewers.

With:
With: Amiram Goldin, Tilda Goldin. (Hebrew, Arabic dialogue)

Director-writer Tzipi Trope’s well intentioned docu, “Looking for the Lost Voice,” unfortunately proves that it takes more than a family’s grief and a plea for peace to make a compelling film. This effort, based on the death of an Israeli army officer and punk band vocalist in a suicide bombing, won’t draw many interested viewers.

On Aug. 4, 2002, Omri Goldin, a sergeant in the Israeli army and the lead vocalist for a punk band called Lucy’s Pussy, was killed in a suicide bus bombing in Galilee; his girlfriend was able to survive because Goldin’s body absorbed the shock and shrapnel. Goldin’s father, Amiram, was already involved in the Peace Now movement and the construction of a co-ooperative Palestinian-Israeli industrial complex in Galilee. Omri’s death fueled his passion for peace and stability.

Unfortunately, Trope fails to widen the story to make it more than a family’s mourning and a restatement of what ails the Middle East.

Amiram Goldin was, apparently, a military man who retired and took his familty to Galilee because he thought it was the Tuscany or Provence of Israel. It didn’t turn out that way. “We were sitting on a barrel of gunpowder” that was about to explode betwen Arabs and Jews, he says, so he got involved with the peace movement.

Then his son was killed. How it fails to embitter him is never explored very deeply here. In addition, there are many unanswered questions — Omri’s 53-year-old mother Tilda, for instance, becomes pregnant within months after her son ‘s death.

There are also several sequences featuring Lucy’s Pussy. The band’s unremarkable music punctuates the proceedings with incongruous results: Trope’s insistence on showing Omri’s parents’ game but bewildered response to the music adds an unintended pathos.

Looking For The Lost Voice

Israel

Production: A Maya Films presentation of a Tzipi Trope production. Produced, directed, written by Trope.

Crew: Camera (color, DV), Tali Godar; editor, Gili Gaon; music, Lucy's Pussy, Paul Thompson. Reviewed on DVD, Los Angeles, April 8, 2005. (In Tribeca Film Festival -- competing.) Running time: 70 MIN.

With: With: Amiram Goldin, Tilda Goldin. (Hebrew, Arabic dialogue)

More Film

  • (L-R) Jodi Kantor and Megan Twohey

    Annapurna, Plan B Developing Movie on New York Times' Harvey Weinstein Investigation

    Director-writer Tzipi Trope’s well intentioned docu, “Looking for the Lost Voice,” unfortunately proves that it takes more than a family’s grief and a plea for peace to make a compelling film. This effort, based on the death of an Israeli army officer and punk band vocalist in a suicide bombing, won’t draw many interested viewers. […]

  • 'United Skates' Review

    Tribeca Film Review: 'United Skates'

    Director-writer Tzipi Trope’s well intentioned docu, “Looking for the Lost Voice,” unfortunately proves that it takes more than a family’s grief and a plea for peace to make a compelling film. This effort, based on the death of an Israeli army officer and punk band vocalist in a suicide bombing, won’t draw many interested viewers. […]

  • A Quiet Place

    'A Quiet Place' Sequel in the Works at Paramount

    Director-writer Tzipi Trope’s well intentioned docu, “Looking for the Lost Voice,” unfortunately proves that it takes more than a family’s grief and a plea for peace to make a compelling film. This effort, based on the death of an Israeli army officer and punk band vocalist in a suicide bombing, won’t draw many interested viewers. […]

  • Adam Aron AMC

    AMC Chief Talks MoviePass, Saudi Arabia, and the Health of the Theater Business

    Director-writer Tzipi Trope’s well intentioned docu, “Looking for the Lost Voice,” unfortunately proves that it takes more than a family’s grief and a plea for peace to make a compelling film. This effort, based on the death of an Israeli army officer and punk band vocalist in a suicide bombing, won’t draw many interested viewers. […]

  • Amber Heard Run Away With Me

    Amber Heard Joins Elisabeth Moss in Drama 'Her Smell' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Director-writer Tzipi Trope’s well intentioned docu, “Looking for the Lost Voice,” unfortunately proves that it takes more than a family’s grief and a plea for peace to make a compelling film. This effort, based on the death of an Israeli army officer and punk band vocalist in a suicide bombing, won’t draw many interested viewers. […]

  • 'Diane' Review: Mary Kay Place Is

    Tribeca Film Review: Mary Kay Place in 'Diane'

    Director-writer Tzipi Trope’s well intentioned docu, “Looking for the Lost Voice,” unfortunately proves that it takes more than a family’s grief and a plea for peace to make a compelling film. This effort, based on the death of an Israeli army officer and punk band vocalist in a suicide bombing, won’t draw many interested viewers. […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content