Review: ‘El Perro Negro: Stories from the Spanish Civil War’

As both intimate history and elegaic poetry, "El Perro Negro: Stories From the Spanish Civil War" is a remarkable, one-of-a-kind work that will follow the same career trajectory as many of the better recent documentaries -- fest crowds, crix raves, awards aplenty and, with any luck, a lingering place in the common consciousness.

As both intimate history and elegaic poetry, “El Perro Negro: Stories From the Spanish Civil War” is a remarkable, one-of-a-kind work that will follow the same career trajectory as many of the better recent documentaries — fest crowds, crix raves, awards aplenty and, with any luck, a lingering place in the common consciousness.

Using the established m.o. of director Peter Forgacs, “El Perro Negro” uses period amateur filmmaking to create an illuminating story of the Republican era that includes the conflicting interests of money and labor, which festered all through ’30s Spain. Treatment is far more thorough than the usual romantic accounts of the much-mythologized time, a la “For Whom the Bells Toll,” which told the story of a freely elected government crushed under the fascist jackboot.

“El Perro Negro” evokes names long lost to the violence of the era, including Catalan wool merchant Jose Salvans i Pierra and leftist Jose Ernesto Diaz Noriega, men who found themselves on opposite sides of an international conflict, and whose cinematography provides Forgacs with the foundation for his movie.

Their imagery is unimaginable anywhere but in the film cans of the period: family gatherings, marketplaces, people playing at revolution and executions, and the various mundane aspects of life, which, given Forgacs’ context, are magnified, even glorified.

Salvans and Noriega aren’t the only amateur directors whose film is included here, but they are the most prominent and, in Salvans’ case, the most poignant: By default part of the moneyed elite, Salvans was fairly apolitical but was murdered nonetheless by one of the more brutal members of the Franco resistance. Noriega, who was taken prisoner, managed, even during his imprisonment, to shoot film.

Much of “El Perro Negro” is like a Robert Capa photo in motion, although Forgacs would probably refuse such a compliment simply because Capa’s record of the Spanish Civil War has become so synonymous with the shorthand version of the conflict. “El Perro Negro,” strenuously evenhanded, is deliberately unsentimental. As result, it feels honest and true.

Transfer and look of the antique footage — notably, the obscure 9.5mm film introduced in the ’20s by Pathe as homemovie stock — is superb.

El Perro Negro: Stories from the Spanish Civil War

Netherlands

Production

A Lumen Films, VPRO-Television production, in association with ARTE/France, YLE/TV1 and Sveriges Television, with support of the Netherlands Film Fund and CoBo Fund. (International sales: Lumen Films). Produced by Cesar Messemaker. Directed, written by Peter Forgacs.

Crew

Camera (color, B&W, 8mm/9.5mm/16mm-to-Digibeta), Jose Ernesto Diaz Noriega, Jose Salvans i Pierra, Ignacio Salvans i Pierra, Modest Solsona, Isodoro Navarette, Daniel Jorro Deprit, Jesus Visa, Juan Vallbona, Russell Palmer; editor, Kati Juhasz; music, Tibor Szemzo; sound, Tamas Zanyi, Rudolf Varhegi. Reviewed at Tribeca Film Festival, April 23, 2005. Running time: 84 MIN.

With

Jose Ernesto Diaz Noriega, Jose Salvans i Pierra, Francisco Franco. Narrators: Miklos Bodoczky, Fernando Bujarrabal, Peter Forgacs, Nils Blunck.
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety

Loading