You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Oscar bans Italo entry

Costanzo's drama is in Arabic, Hebrew and English

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences has rejected Italy’s foreign-language Oscar candidate, “Private,” because it is not “predominantly” in Italian.

First-time helmer Saverio Costanzo’s drama, about a Palestinian family trapped in its home by Israeli soldiers, is in Arabic, Hebrew and English. No Italian is spoken and there are no Italians in the cast.

“The rules for the category allow us no latitude,” said Academy executive director Bruce Davis in a letter faxed to Italo motion picture org Anica on Thursday.

“Each country’s entry must be ‘predominantly in an official language of the country submitting the film,’ ” read the Academy’s letter, quoting eligibility rules.

“Private” was a surprise choice by a new 15-member selection committee that included helmer Bernardo Bertolucci.

An Anica spokesman said that the trade org knew the eligibility rules, but it was up to producers who submit entries and to the committee to make sure the films were eligible.

Anica will submit another pic for Oscar consideration.

Produced by Italo state film entity Istituto Luce with RAI Cinema, DV-shot “Private” scooped the Locarno fest Golden Leopard and actor nods in 2004, and Italy’s David di Donatello for debuting director this year.

Originally skedded to be shot in Israel, pic was lensed in southern Italy for security reasons.

“This news is devastating,” lamented Istituto Luce topper Luciano Sovena. “I believe there is a margin for discretion that should have been applied.”

The Luce topper, who is an entertainment lawyer, cited helmer Gillo Pontecorvo’s 1967 “The Battle of Algiers,” in French, English and Arabic, as an example of an Italian film not in the Italian language that was nominated in the foreign-language category.

“Does this mean Italians can only make movies in Italian that are about Italy?” said Sovena. “We have lawyers in Italy and Los Angeles working on this. We are going to take action to appeal this decision.”

More Film

  • IDFA: Profile of IDFA’s Bertha Fund

    IDFA: The Bertha Fund At 20 – ‘Bringing In New Voices, Other Stories’

    The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences has rejected Italy’s foreign-language Oscar candidate, “Private,” because it is not “predominantly” in Italian. First-time helmer Saverio Costanzo’s drama, about a Palestinian family trapped in its home by Israeli soldiers, is in Arabic, Hebrew and English. No Italian is spoken and there are no Italians in the […]

  • IDFA: Håvard Bustnes On ‘Golden Dawn

    IDFA Golden Dawn Girls Director Håvard Bustnes, ‘The Far Right Movement Is Marching Again’

    The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences has rejected Italy’s foreign-language Oscar candidate, “Private,” because it is not “predominantly” in Italian. First-time helmer Saverio Costanzo’s drama, about a Palestinian family trapped in its home by Israeli soldiers, is in Arabic, Hebrew and English. No Italian is spoken and there are no Italians in the […]

  • Justice League

    Korea Box Office: 'Justice League' on Top as Foreign Films Dominate

    The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences has rejected Italy’s foreign-language Oscar candidate, “Private,” because it is not “predominantly” in Italian. First-time helmer Saverio Costanzo’s drama, about a Palestinian family trapped in its home by Israeli soldiers, is in Arabic, Hebrew and English. No Italian is spoken and there are no Italians in the […]

  • Amsterdam, 19 november 2009.IDFA 2009.Caspar Sonnen.Foto

    IDFA DocLab’s Caspar Sonnen: ‘We Can No Longer Just Blame Technology For Everything’

    The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences has rejected Italy’s foreign-language Oscar candidate, “Private,” because it is not “predominantly” in Italian. First-time helmer Saverio Costanzo’s drama, about a Palestinian family trapped in its home by Israeli soldiers, is in Arabic, Hebrew and English. No Italian is spoken and there are no Italians in the […]

  • Charles Manson Hospitalized

    Charles Manson Dies at 83

    The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences has rejected Italy’s foreign-language Oscar candidate, “Private,” because it is not “predominantly” in Italian. First-time helmer Saverio Costanzo’s drama, about a Palestinian family trapped in its home by Israeli soldiers, is in Arabic, Hebrew and English. No Italian is spoken and there are no Italians in the […]

  • ‘Los Perros’, ‘To Let’ win Kolkata

    ‘Los Perros’, ‘To Let’ win Kolkata Festival

    The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences has rejected Italy’s foreign-language Oscar candidate, “Private,” because it is not “predominantly” in Italian. First-time helmer Saverio Costanzo’s drama, about a Palestinian family trapped in its home by Israeli soldiers, is in Arabic, Hebrew and English. No Italian is spoken and there are no Italians in the […]

  • 'Amal' Review: A Politically Charged Egyptian

    IDFA Film Review: 'Amal'

    The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences has rejected Italy’s foreign-language Oscar candidate, “Private,” because it is not “predominantly” in Italian. First-time helmer Saverio Costanzo’s drama, about a Palestinian family trapped in its home by Israeli soldiers, is in Arabic, Hebrew and English. No Italian is spoken and there are no Italians in the […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content