‘Merry’ pick galls rejected producers

Chosen pic's eligibility questioned

PARIS — The choice of Christian Carion’s World War I-set “Joyeux Noel” (Merry Christmas) to rep France in Oscar’s foreign-language race has sparked a local spat.

Producers of shortlisted pics “Live and Become” and “March of the Penguins” claim that “Merry Christmas” is ineligible because it won’t have had a normal release before the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences’ cutoff date, and it hasn’t tallied 200,000 admissions in France, a Gallic requirement.

“We aren’t trying to be spoilsports, but the selection of ‘Merry Christmas’ is astounding,” said Marie Masmonteil, producer of “Live and Become.” “It’s as if the regulations are there to be broken.”

The Centre National de la Cinematographie said the 200,000-admissions rule isn’t binding. But French producers wishing to submit a film are told by CNC that it is one of the selection conditions.

More important, the Societe des Producteurs Independents (SPI) claims Carion’s $22 million drama, which Sony Pictures Classics will release Stateside in March, breaks an Acad rule.

Pic, based on the true story of a frontline truce between soldiers on Christmas Eve 1914, bowed Sept. 21 at a small arthouse theater in St. Pol-sur-Ternoise, near where it was shot. This fulfills the requirement that foreign-language Oscar candidates must have screened in their own country for at least seven consecutive days between Oct. 1 and Sept. 30. It will go nationwide in November.

The SPI quotes from the Academy’s rulebook that eligible films must be “advertised and exploited in a manner considered normal and customary to the industry.” “This clearly isn’t a normal release by French standards,” Masmonteil said.

In St. Pol on Thursday with Carion to promote “Merry Christmas,” producer Christophe Rossignon dismissed the rumpus.

“I’m confident we are not in breach of the regulations,” he said.

More Film

  • Paul Thomas Anderson Debuts 'Phantom Thread'

    Paul Thomas Anderson Unveils Daniel Day-Lewis Fashion Romance 'Phantom Thread'

    PARIS — The choice of Christian Carion’s World War I-set “Joyeux Noel” (Merry Christmas) to rep France in Oscar’s foreign-language race has sparked a local spat. Producers of shortlisted pics “Live and Become” and “March of the Penguins” claim that “Merry Christmas” is ineligible because it won’t have had a normal release before the Academy […]

  • Peter Baldwin

    Emmy-Winning TV Director Peter Baldwin Dies at 86

    PARIS — The choice of Christian Carion’s World War I-set “Joyeux Noel” (Merry Christmas) to rep France in Oscar’s foreign-language race has sparked a local spat. Producers of shortlisted pics “Live and Become” and “March of the Penguins” claim that “Merry Christmas” is ineligible because it won’t have had a normal release before the Academy […]

  • Peddling Pictures launches with Discovery’s ‘Prison

    Peddling Pictures Launches With Discovery’s ‘Prison Food’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    PARIS — The choice of Christian Carion’s World War I-set “Joyeux Noel” (Merry Christmas) to rep France in Oscar’s foreign-language race has sparked a local spat. Producers of shortlisted pics “Live and Become” and “March of the Penguins” claim that “Merry Christmas” is ineligible because it won’t have had a normal release before the Academy […]

  • SGIFF: Controversial ‘Sexy Durga’ set for

    SGIFF: Controversial ‘Sexy Durga’ set for Singapore Debut

    PARIS — The choice of Christian Carion’s World War I-set “Joyeux Noel” (Merry Christmas) to rep France in Oscar’s foreign-language race has sparked a local spat. Producers of shortlisted pics “Live and Become” and “March of the Penguins” claim that “Merry Christmas” is ineligible because it won’t have had a normal release before the Academy […]

  • Taiwan's 'Cock Robin' Heads for North

    Taiwan's 'Cock Robin' Heads for North America With Cheng Cheng

    PARIS — The choice of Christian Carion’s World War I-set “Joyeux Noel” (Merry Christmas) to rep France in Oscar’s foreign-language race has sparked a local spat. Producers of shortlisted pics “Live and Become” and “March of the Penguins” claim that “Merry Christmas” is ineligible because it won’t have had a normal release before the Academy […]

  • Michael Pena Extinction sold

    Michael Pena-Lizzy Caplan Movie 'Extinction' Disappears From Universal Schedule

    PARIS — The choice of Christian Carion’s World War I-set “Joyeux Noel” (Merry Christmas) to rep France in Oscar’s foreign-language race has sparked a local spat. Producers of shortlisted pics “Live and Become” and “March of the Penguins” claim that “Merry Christmas” is ineligible because it won’t have had a normal release before the Academy […]

  • Orange Poaches EuropaCorp's Sales Exec Andreï

    Orange Poaches EuropaCorp's Sales Exec Andreï Kamarowsky to Run Sales for New Film/TV Division

    PARIS — The choice of Christian Carion’s World War I-set “Joyeux Noel” (Merry Christmas) to rep France in Oscar’s foreign-language race has sparked a local spat. Producers of shortlisted pics “Live and Become” and “March of the Penguins” claim that “Merry Christmas” is ineligible because it won’t have had a normal release before the Academy […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content