Review: ‘The Dick Van Dyke Show Revisited’

Unexpected as it is for a fluffy bit of sweeps-timed nostalgia to actually provoke hunger for more, that's the case with this warm and breezy tribute, an almost casual cast reunion augmented by classic clips. Cleverly conceived by Carl Reiner, who is among those to reprise roles from the original series, what's billed as the "159th episode" provides a solid reminder as to why this deservedly remains one of TV's most-beloved comedies.

Unexpected as it is for a fluffy bit of sweeps-timed nostalgia to actually provoke hunger for more, that’s the case with this warm and breezy tribute, an almost casual cast reunion augmented by classic clips. Cleverly conceived by Carl Reiner, who is among those to reprise roles from the original series, what’s billed as the “159th episode” provides a solid reminder as to why this deservedly remains one of TV’s most-beloved comedies.

Nostalgia became big business after a Carol Burnett spec made a surprising sweeps splash in 2001, and “Dick Van Dyke Revisited” represents a pleasant addition to what has too often been a slapdash genre.

The show’s namesake and his co-star Mary Tyler Moore look especially dapper four decades later, even gratuitously showing off the dancing prowess and gams, respectively, that helped propel their careers. (Moore was legendarily the unseen secretary, except for her legs, of “Richard Diamond, Private Detective” before landing the part of Laura.)

The wispy excuse for the retrospective, beyond a desire to draw a bigger audience than “Century City” did, has Alan Brady (Reiner) deciding he needs a worthy eulogy and soliciting former writers Rob (Van Dyke) and Sally (Rose Marie) to write it — for a handsome fee, of course.

Having given up New Rochelle for New York, both Rob and Laura (Moore) would like the money, but not surprisingly feel there’s something ghoulish about collaborating on, and profiting from, an obit with the dead-guy-to-be. Besides, as Rob asks, how do you write “a heartfelt eulogy for someone with no heart.”

The setup brings everyone to Brady’s house, including neighbor Millie (Ann Morgan Guilbert) and Rob’s brother Stacey (Jerry Van Dyke), where, through clips, they reminisce about characters such as Buddy and Mel, played by the late Morey Amsterdam and Richard Deacon.

Despite a brief intro on the black-and-white living room set (later shown in color) and funny capper involving Ray Romano, this is little more than a chance to see Van Dyke and Moore, especially, don old clothes that still fit remarkably well. Laura even exhibits a bit of an edge, informing the famously chrome-domed Brady that Rob “still has all his hair, every last strand of it.”

Never mind that the cast is well beyond anybody’s target demo, this is a helluva lot funnier than “Still Standing.” Rob even uses minor epithets like “hell” and “damn” — a development Laura attributes to getting cable, in one of Reiner’s more wry asides.

(A small disclaimer here: Van Dyke wrote my former newspaper a few years ago to say I must have something against the elderly, citing old-fogey references to his last series, “Diagnosis Murder.” His 70-plus years notwithstanding, he expressed confidence that he could still kick my butt. We subsequently made peace, though discretion being the better part of valor, I’m reluctant to rile him again unless there is an ottoman nearby that I might push him over.)

“Van Dyke Revisited” is clearly modest in execution and aspirations, yet when it comes to these characters, like Rob, I’m still a bit of a pushover.

The Dick Van Dyke Show Revisited

CBS, Tue. May 11, 9 p.m.

Production

Produced by TV Land Prods. Executive producer, Carl Reiner; producers, Sal Maniaci, Michael Petok; director, Ken Whittingham; writer, Reiner.

Crew

Camera, Victor Nelli Jr.; editor, Michael Karlich; music, Paul Buckley; production designer, Jefferson Sage; clip segments producer, Paul Brownstein; casting, Sharon Lieblein. 60 MIN.

Cast

Rob Petrie - Dick Van Dyke Laura Petrie - Mary Tyler Moore Alan Brady - Carl Reiner Sally Rogers - Rose Marie Millie Helper - Ann Morgan Guilbert Stacey Petrie - Jerry Van Dyke Richie Petrie - Larry Mathews Herman Glimcher - Bill Idelson

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Scene News from Variety

Loading