Review: ‘Roar’

Scratch the inane title. Despite its ethnic roots in the Palestinian Diaspora entrenched in Detroit, Betty Shamieh's second play is not in the least ferocious. Play tells the familiar story of how children who grow up in discontented families are doomed to inherit their unrealized dreams. Production is lucky to have a bang-up cast.

Scratch the inane title. Despite its ethnic roots in the Palestinian Diaspora entrenched in Detroit, Betty Shamieh’s second play (after “Chocolate in Heat”) is not in the least ferocious. Cast in the structural conventions of the domestic drama, play tells the old familiar story of how children who grow up in discontented families are doomed to inherit their unrealized dreams. Scribe livens up the formula by applying it to characters whose highly individualized personalities have been shaped (and, in some ways, misshapen) by their shared cultural heritage. Since textual holes keep the script from being actor-proof, production is lucky to have a bang-up cast guided by Marion McClinton’s pro directorial hand.

Although the full story doesn’t come out until the end of the play, here’s the gist: Back in the old country — Jordan — sisters Karema (Sarita Choudhury) and Hala (Annabella Sciorra) were romanced by brothers Ahmed (Joseph Kamal) and Abe (Daniel Oreskes). As a popular singer of traditional Arabic folksongs, Hala would have been the natural mate for Ahmed, a celebrated composer and musician. With their common talent for making shrewd and hard-headed business deals, Karema and Abe also would seem to have been fated for one another.

But love rarely proves to be the meeting of true minds that it’s cracked up to be, and when the play opens, Karema and Ahmed are old marrieds living in a cramped apartment in Detroit. Although they own a neighborhood bodega and income-producing real estate, their lives are pinched and joyless, a fact conveyed by the drab and tasteless furnishings of Beowulf Boritt’s dismal set. Ahmed has given up his music, Karema has turned into a miserly shrew and, for reasons that aren’t entirely convincing, Abe, a successful music producer, is not welcome in their home.

Not surprisingly, family tensions have made a contrarian of the couple’s teen daughter Irene, who is determined to have a singing career. Although it seems pretty obvious that her talents do not lie in this direction, neither the playwright nor Sherri Eldin, who plays the part with more ungainly energy than is needed, provides dramatic clues as to where her true talents do lie. Nevertheless, the audience is expected to take it on faith that the kid has something going in the creativity department — something that is stirred when Auntie Hala shows up for an unexpected visit.

As Hala the housebreaker, Sciorra shows terrific versatility in the art of body language. Flaunting her shapely frame in Mattie Ullrich’s gaudy costumes, she shows Hala for what she appears to be — a high-maintenance mistress whose Kuwaiti lover tossed her out when Iraq invaded the country (the year is 1991) and declared Palestinians personae non grata. Using her delicate features to speak a more subtle language, Sciorra shows a vulnerable side of Hala that redeems her character more than words, even as she sends the entire household into a tailspin.

The dynamic of the play, which turns on the character transformations that result from the catalytic presence of Hala in the house, is artfully executed by McClinton and company. But no directorial sleight-of-hand can pick up the slack in the loose plot, which lacks sharp and pointed indicators of where it’s headed. And although close encounters between individual characters play well, the big payoff scene that every domestic drama has to have to earn its chops — that free-for-all bloodbath of bottled-up revelations and recriminations that really tears the skin off every member of the family — never materializes.

Shamieh has given it a good shot. But before sitting down to do her rewrite, she ought to re-read Arthur Miller’s “The Price.”


Harold Clurman Theater; 99 seats; $50


A New Group presentation of a new play in two acts by Betty Shamieh. Directed by Marion McClinton.


Sets, Beowulf Boritt; costumes, Mattie Ullrich; lighting, Jason Lyons; sound, Ken Travis; production stage manager, Valerie A. Peterson. Artistic director, Scott Elliott. Opened April 7, 2004. Reviewed April 23. Running time: 2 HOURS


Karema - Sarita Choudhury Irene - Sherri Eldin Ahmed - Joseph Kamal Hala - Annabella Sciorra Abe - Daniel Oreskes

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Legit News from Variety