Keep ratings credible

Variety editorial

Boffo box office for the R-rated “The Matrix Reloaded” may be cause for celebration, but the film’s huge success says something less encouraging about the difficulties of enforcing the Motion Picture Assn. of America’s ratings system.

Hollywood could not ask for a more impassioned and thoughtful advocate than Jack Valenti, but his defense of the 35-year-old ratings system is increasingly unconvincing because it can’t be adequately implemented.

Take “Reloaded.” Warner Bros. reported that 50% of opening-weekend crowds were under 25 and that for many folks the film became a family event.

Producer Joel Silver reasoned that “the audience rated the movie.”

Exhibitors, meanwhile, just two years removed from a bitter feud with Washington over kids’ access to violent fare, simply threw up their hands. Given how many screens exhibitors pack under one roof, enforcing MPAA ratings is nearly impossible.

If the studio positions “Reloaded” as a family film and theater owners lack resources to make sure those under 17 don’t get in, how credible can the ratings system be?

This phenom is set to repeat itself all summer, with the release of R-rated titles like “Bad Boys 2,” “Terminator 3,” “American Wedding” and “Gigli.”

While we believe filmmakers have the right to make edgy and challenging works — and inevitably they will try to get them in front of as many ticket-buyers as possible — we think exhibitors, in concert with the MPAA, need to be held accountable for whom they allow into restricted movies.

If they aren’t, D.C. politicos could decide to take on this summer’s slew of R-rated tentpoles for their own purposes.

More Scene

  • LOS ANGELES, CA - MAY 19:

    'Stranger Things' Team Offers Glimpses Into Season 3 at Netflix FYSee

    Boffo box office for the R-rated “The Matrix Reloaded” may be cause for celebration, but the film’s huge success says something less encouraging about the difficulties of enforcing the Motion Picture Assn. of America’s ratings system. Hollywood could not ask for a more impassioned and thoughtful advocate than Jack Valenti, but his defense of the […]

  • 'Pose' TV show premiere

    Ryan Murphy Wants 'Pose' to Be 'Uplifting' for LGBTQ Community in Trump Era

    Boffo box office for the R-rated “The Matrix Reloaded” may be cause for celebration, but the film’s huge success says something less encouraging about the difficulties of enforcing the Motion Picture Assn. of America’s ratings system. Hollywood could not ask for a more impassioned and thoughtful advocate than Jack Valenti, but his defense of the […]

  • DISNEY CHANNEL - "Disney Channel GO!

    Disney Channel Stars Meet With Fans at First Ever Fan Fest

    Boffo box office for the R-rated “The Matrix Reloaded” may be cause for celebration, but the film’s huge success says something less encouraging about the difficulties of enforcing the Motion Picture Assn. of America’s ratings system. Hollywood could not ask for a more impassioned and thoughtful advocate than Jack Valenti, but his defense of the […]

  • Sweet Spots Post-Cannes Retreats: Portugal, Provence

    Sweet Spots for Post-Cannes Retreats: Portugal, Provence and London

    Boffo box office for the R-rated “The Matrix Reloaded” may be cause for celebration, but the film’s huge success says something less encouraging about the difficulties of enforcing the Motion Picture Assn. of America’s ratings system. Hollywood could not ask for a more impassioned and thoughtful advocate than Jack Valenti, but his defense of the […]

  • Debra Birnbaum, Liz Flahive, Carly Mensch,

    Women of Netflix, Gabrielle Carteris on the Need for Female Mentorship in TV

    Boffo box office for the R-rated “The Matrix Reloaded” may be cause for celebration, but the film’s huge success says something less encouraging about the difficulties of enforcing the Motion Picture Assn. of America’s ratings system. Hollywood could not ask for a more impassioned and thoughtful advocate than Jack Valenti, but his defense of the […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content