Butt out

Variety Editorial

In their latest anti-tobacco initiative, the attorneys general of 24 states have turned their attention to Hollywood.

The same group that has been gnawing at the ankles of Big Tobacco for years sent a letter last week to Motion Picture Assn. of America topper Jack Valenti. It called upon the film industry to reduce the amount of smoking in movies in order to prevent teens from taking up the habit. A pediatrician who led a recent study cited in the letter even urged an automatic R rating for smoke-filled films.

Please.

This muddled argument does not advance the cause of health. It brazenly intrudes on filmmakers’ rights to depict situations in which, for reasons of period or character authenticity, people smoke. Films like “Casablanca” or “The Best Years of Their Lives” would hardly have been the same films without smoking. Even films about World War II made today would be hard-pressed to avoid it.

If the MPAA were to factor smoking into its ratings, what about other societal issues like the depiction of women or the use of racial stereotypes?

Smoking kills. We agree that it should be legislated and limited to some extent. It isn’t 1948; it’s 2003 and the public health toll is too great to roll back those restrictions.

But the arts are another matter. Evidence of a cause-and-effect relationship between young viewers and what is on screen is not compelling. The industry has never achieved a consensus on keeping smoking out of films, despite initiatives by industry leaders such as Joe Roth. There is a good reason for that. Trying to dictate content crosses a dangerous line.

More Scene

  • 'Patrick Melrose' TV show premiere

    Benedict Cumberbatch Calls 'Patrick Melrose' His 'Passion Project'

    In their latest anti-tobacco initiative, the attorneys general of 24 states have turned their attention to Hollywood. The same group that has been gnawing at the ankles of Big Tobacco for years sent a letter last week to Motion Picture Assn. of America topper Jack Valenti. It called upon the film industry to reduce the […]

  • 'Cobra Kai' premiere

    ‘Cobra Kai’: Why Ralph Macchio Revisited 'Karate Kid' Character After 30 Years

    In their latest anti-tobacco initiative, the attorneys general of 24 states have turned their attention to Hollywood. The same group that has been gnawing at the ankles of Big Tobacco for years sent a letter last week to Motion Picture Assn. of America topper Jack Valenti. It called upon the film industry to reduce the […]

  • Robert Downey Jr'Avengers: Infinity War' film

    'Avengers: Infinity War' Premiere Draws Largest Contingent of Marvel Superheroes

    In their latest anti-tobacco initiative, the attorneys general of 24 states have turned their attention to Hollywood. The same group that has been gnawing at the ankles of Big Tobacco for years sent a letter last week to Motion Picture Assn. of America topper Jack Valenti. It called upon the film industry to reduce the […]

  • 'The Week Of' film premiere

    'The Week Of' Director Talks Reuniting With Adam Sandler After 'SNL'

    In their latest anti-tobacco initiative, the attorneys general of 24 states have turned their attention to Hollywood. The same group that has been gnawing at the ankles of Big Tobacco for years sent a letter last week to Motion Picture Assn. of America topper Jack Valenti. It called upon the film industry to reduce the […]

  • Beautycon Festival

    Laverne Cox, Paris Hilton Promote Self-Love at Beautycon NYC

    In their latest anti-tobacco initiative, the attorneys general of 24 states have turned their attention to Hollywood. The same group that has been gnawing at the ankles of Big Tobacco for years sent a letter last week to Motion Picture Assn. of America topper Jack Valenti. It called upon the film industry to reduce the […]

  • Duke and Duchess of Cambridge

    The Duchess of Cambridge Gives Birth to Baby Boy

    In their latest anti-tobacco initiative, the attorneys general of 24 states have turned their attention to Hollywood. The same group that has been gnawing at the ankles of Big Tobacco for years sent a letter last week to Motion Picture Assn. of America topper Jack Valenti. It called upon the film industry to reduce the […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content