Review: ‘Ten Minutes Older: The Cello’

This companion piece to "Ten Minutes Older: The Trumpet," which premiered earlier this year at Cannes, is very much the same mixture. Concept is to allow several well-known Euro art directors complete freedom to make a short film running exactly 10 minutes on any subject and in any style. The format is better suited to TV.

This companion piece to “Ten Minutes Older: The Trumpet,” which premiered earlier this year at Cannes, is very much the same mixture. Concept is to allow several well-known Euro art directors complete freedom to make a short film running exactly 10 minutes on any subject and in any style. The format is better suited to TV and ancillary than to cinema release (“Trumpet” aired on Showtime in the U.S.), though festivals will want to program both films despite the uneven quality of the material.

In “Cello,” Czech director Jiri Menzel produces the most telling contribution, triumphing over the formula to make an extremely simple tribute to his friend, late actor Rudolf Hrusinsky. Consisting simply of scenes from films in which Hrusinsky appeared during his long career, “One Moment” is an eloquent testament to the ravages of time as the handsome young man, captured on film over a long period, morphs into a middle-aged and finally very old man before our eyes. Simple concept is filled with humanity and a touching sense of vulnerability, plus Menzel’s trademark sense of humor.

Jean-Luc Godard’s “In the Darkness of Time” uses film clips from his work and others to illustrate the finality of a number of aspects of life. “The last minutes of youth” are illustrated by the scene of Jean-Pierre Leaud’s death in “Made in U.S.A.,” for example, and “The last minutes of silence” depicts the torture scene from “The Little Soldier.” As always, the indelible image of Anna Karina, weeping, in “Vivre sa vie” provides an achingly poignant moment, but Godard isn’t saying anything here he hasn’t said before.

Istvan Szabo contributes a beautifully filmed but rather pointless anecdote, which shows how little time it takes to change the direction of someone’s life. A woman (Ildiko Bansagi) awaits the return home of her husband (Gabor Mate) for a birthday celebration; he arrives drunk and there’s a fatal confrontation. Lajos Koltai’s fluid camerawork is the principal pleasure here.

Bernardo Bertolucci’s segment, which kicks off the film, depicts the passing of time as based on an Indian story. A group of Indians walk through the Italian countryside; a young man leaves an old man sitting under a tree and goes to get water but is waylaid when he meets a woman. They fall in love, marry, have a son, and years go by — but the old man still waits under the tree for his water.

Michael Radford’s sci-fi seg also plays with the notion of time; after a long voyage into space, an astronaut returns home to discover he’s now younger than his son.

Mike Figgis provides another of his four-screen presentations, but the innovative director seems to have painted himself into a corner with this style of experimental video-making and provides nothing new here.

Volker Schlondorff, inspired by Augustinus (354-430 A.D.), tells an anecdote about racism, but the points are handled without much finesse.

In the weakest seg, Claire Denis films an argument about immigration on a train in which a philosopher debates the subject with one of his students. Very dry, very French.

While none of the famous names featured here is at his or her best, it’s always interesting to see what they’ll come up with in this kind of format. The segments are separated by images of water accompanied by plaintive cello music (in comparison to the original mix’s jazzy trumpet), and all eight are professional packaged.

Ten Minutes Older: The Cello



HISTORY OF WATER Directed, written by Bernardo Bertolucci. ABOUT TIME 2 Directed, written by Mike Figgis ONE MOMENT Directed, written by Jiri Menzel. TEN MINUTES AFTER Directed, written by Istvan Szabo. TOWARDS NANCY Directed, written by Claire Denis. THE ENLIGHTENMENT Directed by Volker Schlondorff. Screenplay, Max Frye, based on "Confessions" by Augustinus. ADDICTED TO THE STARS Directed, written by Michael Radford. IN THE DARKNESS OF TIME Directed by Jean-Luc Godard. Screenplay, Anne-Marie Mieville.


HISTORY OF WATER Camera (B&W), Fabio Cianchetti; editor, Jacopo Quadri; production designer, Metka Kosak; costume designer, Louise Stjvernsward; sound, Tommaso Quattrini. ABOUT TIME 2 Camera (color), Figgis, Danny Cohen, Lucy Bristow, Albert Kodagolian, Kirstin McMahon; production designer, Michael Howells; costume designer, Dinah Collins; sound, Nigel Heath, James Feltham, Mark Tucker. ONE MOMENT Editor, Zdenek Patocka; music, Leos Janacek. TEN MINUTES AFTER Camera (color), Lajos Koltai; editor, Zsuzsa Csakany; production designer, Zsuzsa Borvendeg; costume designers, Zsuzsa Stenger, Sandor Csajbok; sound, Istvan Sipos. TOWARDS NANCY Camera (B&W), Agnes Godard; editor, Emmanuelle Pencalet; music, Brice Leboucq; sound, Jean-Louis Ughetto, Paulin Sagna. THE ENLIGHTENMENT Camera (color), Tilman Buttner, Andreas Hofer; editors, Peter Przygodda, Oliver Weiss; production designer, Claus-Jurgen Pfeiffer; costume designer, Aenne Plaumann. ADDICTED TO THE STARS Camera (color), Pascal Rabaud; editor, Lucia Zucchetti; music, Jocelyn Pook; production designer, Christina Moore; costume designer, Jany Temime. IN THE DARKNESS OF TIME Camera (color), Julien Hirsch; music, Arvo Part; sound, Francois Musy. All reviewed at Venice Film Festival (noncompeting), Sept. 3, 2002. (Also in Toronto Film Festival.) Running time: 106 MIN.


HISTORY OF WATER With: Amit Arroz, Valeria Bruni Tadeschi. ABOUT TIME 2 With: Mark Long, Alexandra Staden, Dominic West. ONE MOMENT With: Rudolf Hrusinsky. TEN MINUTES AFTER With: Ildiko Bansagi, Gabor Mate. TOWARDS NANCY With: Jean-Luc Nancy, Ana Samardzija, Alex Descas. THE ENLIGHTENMENT With: Bibiana Beglau, Irm Hermann, Mario Irrek, Toks Korner. ADDICTED TO THE STARS With: Daniel Craig, Charles Simon, Roland Gift, Branka Katic, Claire Adamson.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety