Review: ‘Elsewhere’

"Elsewhere" goes everywhere the viewer has likely never. Doc, lensed by peripatetic Austrian filmmaker Nikolaus Geyrhalter in 12 remote locations in each of the 12 months of the year 2000, brilliantly functions as both a survey of how tribal peoples today function between tradition and modernity and as a fabulous armchair adventure.

Over an incredibly speedy four hours of unspooling, “Elsewhere” goes everywhere the viewer has likely never been on the planet. Doc, lensed by peripatetic Austrian filmmaker Nikolaus Geyrhalter in 12 remote locations in each of the 12 months of the year 2000, brilliantly functions as both a survey of how tribal peoples today function between tradition and modernity and as a fabulous armchair adventure. Though an indelible watching experience at uninterrupted length, opus can be easily split in parts (each one clocking at around 20 minutes) for broadcast it richly deserves on worldwide tubes.

Shooting involved a pre-production schedule starting in August 1998 requiring a massive support group of researchers, translators (involving several lingos rarely if ever heard onscreen), coordinators and prep in each of the dozen locales. To add complications on top of complications, Geyrhalter came down ill after March 2000 lensing in Namibia, but since production could not stop, his assistants took the helm until he soon returned.

Notably, all of these travails are absolutely invisible onscreen, which is generally filled with superbly composed medium, slightly wide-angle shots of indigenous people surviving and sometimes thriving under conditions that those in tech-laden urban centers would shun. Steadfastly refusing to impose his outsider’s commentary on what is seen, Geyrhalter has each person describe in his own words (and frequently in direct-address) what his life is like.

Tribal camel breeders in Ekeschi, Nigeria, have the whole family pitch in on their back-breaking work, but some express mounting concerns about the desertified bush being able to continue to support them. Lonely reindeer hunter Hans Kitti can travel miles on his snowmobile in Finland’s northernmost region without seeing another living being. Multiple marriages seem to be the rule in Kapyarukoro Tjambiru’s Namibia desert home, where he and his two wives offer accounts of how they try to balance labor and emotions. “How to Make a Giant Treehouse” could be title of fourth section on Indonesia’s island of Irian Jaya, where men build an abode high in the treetops.

Seal hunters in Greenland defend their practice, and one blames no less than Brigitte Bardot for campaigning for eco-restrictions on such hunting. Inching toward an uneasy truce with Western influences, Aboriginal mothers in Oz outback village of Manmoyi are seen quietly spending their days with their babies as older kids play Nintendo and dance to ancient music. Strong and independent Tsewang Dolma sustains a full life, though it requires sending her cow herd up to remote northern Indian grasslands that look like the top of the world. Siberian reindeer breeder Josif Kechimov appears bitter at his subsistence life with his family on the wooded tundra plain, badly encroached upon by oil companies he despises but must depend on.

Another woman in charge is Gao ru qi du, 87-year-old matriarch of a home in China’s Yunan province, who seems happy that men are fairly scarce. Sardinian father-and-son fishermen Luigi and Gaetano Garau are closest to anything like a Westernized lifestyle, but theirs is an extremely dangerous livelihood that brings little visible satisfaction.

Nisga’a tribesmen in northern British Columbia speak in English about the art of totem pole building, while elders fret over their tribe’s depleted fisheries. Adventure ends on sad note in Micronesia at Christmastime, when tribespeople on Woleai Atoll wait for a gift drop care of the Red Cross that turns out to be mostly junk.

Cumulative effect is extraordinary, offering a refreshed view of how people live and raise families with little technological aid, yet with increasing dependency on the modern, outside world. Image (in very fine hi-def video transferred to film) and sound are world-class.




A Nikolaus Geyrhalter Filmproduktion production under the patronage of the Austrian Commission for UNESCO and in co-production with Bayerischer Rundfunk/Film and Teleclub/Arte. (International sales: Terranoa, St.-Ouen Cedex, France.) Produced by Nicolaus Geyrhaltar. Directed by Nicolaus Geyrhalter. Research, Silvia Burner, Michael Kitzberger, Wolfgang Widerhofer, Geyrhalter.


Camera (digital video color, Synchro Film and Video prints), Geyrhalter; editor, Widerhofer; sound (Dolby Digital), Stefan Holzer; production managers, Kitzberger, Markus Glaser; location managers, Eva Gretzmacher, Nils John Porsanger, Kos Verwey, Heide Beinhauer, Jill Paley, Kornelius Kembaren, Nicky Mehuem, Irma Turtle, Verena Traeger, Murray Garde, Surjit Singh, Stephen Dudeck, Iris Bubenik-Bauer, Philipp Mayrhofer, Sabrina Peralta, Maria Luisa Melis; project coordinator, Dominik Trimborn. Reviewed at Toronto Film Festival (Real to Reel), Sept 6, 2002. Running time: 240 MIN.


Mohamed Bada, Abardagh Kalka, Boula Kalka, Hans Kitti, Kapyarukoro Tjambiru, Tuaendoveni Tjiundiro, Mukaauatavi Hepute, Nate Handuwop Dambol, Daula Dambol Nambul, Asiajuk Sadorana, Benigne Sadorana, Otto Simigak , Margaret Guymala, Travis Milmarapuy , Tsewang Dolma, Josif Nikitovich Kechimov, Svetlana Nikitovna Kechimova, Vladimir Josifovich Kechimov, Gao ru qi du, Dai shi yong zuo, Luigi Garau, Gaetano Garau, Dennis Nyce, Stephen Nyce, Lavinia Legasugram, Francisco Mairal. (Tamashek, Sami, Ojihimba, Korowai, Kalaallisut, Kunwinjku, Ladakhi, Khanty, Moso, Sardinian, Nisga'a, Faliasch, English dialogue)
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety