You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Smoke no screen

Letter to the Editor

To the Editor:

Joe Eszterhaus, in his guest column (“Stars must quit on-screen ciggies,” Dec. 18), says some people believe that movie stars smoke onscreen because they are paid off by the tobacco companies. But he says he doesn’t believe it. And others think actors smoke onscreen because actors will grab any prop — even a lethal one — to aid a performance, even if Eszterhaus says he doesn’t believe that either.

He goes on to say that stars smoke onscreen because they are so addicted that they can’t stop — not even for the brief spurts which it takes to shoot a scene.

Are you really that goofy, Joe? I’m starting to believe you didn’t really direct the films you are credited with. I’ve directed features and no actor would just use a prop such as a cigarette if I didn’t think it was appropriate for the scene and made sense for the character.

The reason there is so much smoking in film is because certain filmmakers feel it represents a more realistic view of society. They fear of not succeeding at recreating society as it really is. It feeds itself. No matter, the actors are not to blame. The blame falls directly on the producers and directors.

Todd Ryan

More Voices

  • Netflix Cannes

    Cannes vs. Netflix Defines Fight for Cinema’s Future

    To the Editor: Joe Eszterhaus, in his guest column (“Stars must quit on-screen ciggies,” Dec. 18), says some people believe that movie stars smoke onscreen because they are paid off by the tobacco companies. But he says he doesn’t believe it. And others think actors smoke onscreen because actors will grab any prop — even […]

  • Love Never Dies - Utica, NY

    Could 'Love Never Dies' Live Again on Broadway?

    To the Editor: Joe Eszterhaus, in his guest column (“Stars must quit on-screen ciggies,” Dec. 18), says some people believe that movie stars smoke onscreen because they are paid off by the tobacco companies. But he says he doesn’t believe it. And others think actors smoke onscreen because actors will grab any prop — even […]

  • Every Act of Life

    Tribeca Film Festival: 5 Titles to Watch for Theater Fans

    To the Editor: Joe Eszterhaus, in his guest column (“Stars must quit on-screen ciggies,” Dec. 18), says some people believe that movie stars smoke onscreen because they are paid off by the tobacco companies. But he says he doesn’t believe it. And others think actors smoke onscreen because actors will grab any prop — even […]

  • Francis mcdormand Oscar Win Inclusion rider

    How Tax Credits Could Bring About Inclusion in Hollywood (Guest Column)

    To the Editor: Joe Eszterhaus, in his guest column (“Stars must quit on-screen ciggies,” Dec. 18), says some people believe that movie stars smoke onscreen because they are paid off by the tobacco companies. But he says he doesn’t believe it. And others think actors smoke onscreen because actors will grab any prop — even […]

  • New York Theater Critics Online Review

    Broadway Critics Launch New Site for Theater Reviews

    To the Editor: Joe Eszterhaus, in his guest column (“Stars must quit on-screen ciggies,” Dec. 18), says some people believe that movie stars smoke onscreen because they are paid off by the tobacco companies. But he says he doesn’t believe it. And others think actors smoke onscreen because actors will grab any prop — even […]

  • Frozen Broadway

    How Broadway's 'Frozen' Will Surprise Movie Fans

    To the Editor: Joe Eszterhaus, in his guest column (“Stars must quit on-screen ciggies,” Dec. 18), says some people believe that movie stars smoke onscreen because they are paid off by the tobacco companies. But he says he doesn’t believe it. And others think actors smoke onscreen because actors will grab any prop — even […]

  • Alyssa MilanoTelevision Industry Advocacy Awards, Los

    Alyssa Milano: Time to End the Partisan Politics Around Health Care (Guest Column)

    To the Editor: Joe Eszterhaus, in his guest column (“Stars must quit on-screen ciggies,” Dec. 18), says some people believe that movie stars smoke onscreen because they are paid off by the tobacco companies. But he says he doesn’t believe it. And others think actors smoke onscreen because actors will grab any prop — even […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content