Review: ‘Butterfly Smile’

Returning to themes of voyeurism and intervention that he explored in 1995's "Postman," mainland Chinese director He Jianjun shows more stylistic affinity with Euro filmmakers in his fourth feature, "Butterfly Smile." Structured as an enigmatic puzzle, this elegantly made, doleful drama is too attenuated for general arthouse acceptance.

Returning to the themes of voyeurism and intervention in other people’s lives that he explored with penetrating intensity in 1995’s “Postman” — arguably still his best film — mainland Chinese director He Jianjun continues to show more stylistic affinity with European filmmakers like Kieslowski and Antonioni than with his compatriots in his fourth feature, “Butterfly Smile.” Structured as an enigmatic puzzle, this elegantly made, doleful drama is too attenuated for general arthouse acceptance. But its quiet, hypnotic qualities and intriguing characters should ensure further festival bookings. Given more linear treatment, the story has distinct remake possibilities.

Driving home on a winter night, fashion model Meng Xing (Jiang Weiwei) hits a cyclist on a deserted backstreet, causing her to panic and bolt, leaving the gravely injured man out cold on the pavement. A lonely middle-aged computer salesman, Kang Ping (Ge You), witnesses the accident and takes the cyclist to hospital, disappearing before a police report can be filed.

Action then shifts back in time, revealing Kang Ping to be an amateur photographer obsessed with the model. After photographing her at a fashion show, he traces her to an agency run by Lei Ming (Sun Chun), who fails to disclose that he’s Meng Xing’s husband. Feeling his wife is growing apart from him, Lei Ming enlists Kang Ping to photograph her unseen from an apartment opposite the workshop where she designs clothes.

When he witnesses the hit-and-run accident, which resuscitates painful memories from his own past, Kang Ping begins indirectly communicating with Meng Xing. He attempts to make her accept responsibility for her actions, at the same time being wanted by police himself for questioning in connection with the accident.

While director He’s approach is too unhurried to exploit the psychological-thriller aspect inherent in the story, the austere drama remains moody and compelling, accompanied by a melodic score that at times eases into quietly suspenseful mode. Despite being photographed mainly in closeup or mid-shots, the visual style is cool, detached and distant, effectively mirroring the way in which Kang Ping spies on his subject. Best known for his roles in Chen Kaige’s “Farewell, My Concubine” and Zhang Yimou’s “To Live,” Ge provides a strong, sorrowful center to the drama, with both leads keeping emotions under strict control.

Butterfly Smile



A China Film Group Corp./Beijing Film Studio/CCTV Movie Channel production. (International sales: China Film Import & Export Corp., Beijing.) Produced by Tong Gang, Han Sanping, Yan Xiaoming. Executive producers, Li Xiaogeng, Geng Xilin, Liu Changgen. Directed by He Jianjun. Screenplay, He, Liu Xiaojing.


Camera (color), Wu Di; editor, Liu Xiaojing; music, Chen Xiangyu; art director, Liang Dawei; costume designer, Hou Xiaojie; sound (Dolby), Liu Shenshen; assistant director, Du Yuming. Reviewed at San Sebastian Film Festival (competing), Sept. 25, 2001. Running time: 89 MIN.


Kang Ping - Ge You
Meng Xing - Jiang Weiwei
Lei Ming - Sun Chun
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety