Review: ‘Betty Fisher and Other Stories’

Morphing from the serious to the playful, "Betty Fisher and Other Stories" is a delicious confident jeu from France's maverick director, Claude Miller. The film is a psychological thriller detailing a young boy's kidnapping and the series of events set off by the crime. Upscale audiences will enjoy the well-honed Gallic fare.

Slowly morphing from the serious to the playful, and with a script that coaxes the viewer into an elaborately spun web of separate narratives, “Betty Fisher and Other Stories” is a delicious, utterly confident jeu from one of France’s most discreetly maverick directors, Claude Miller. Drawing together a broad range of actors into an off-center but strangely credible universe, pic emerges as an unclassifiable blend of psychological thriller, caper movie, comedy-drama and multi-character criss-crosser, as the kidnapping of a young boy sets off a train of events. Smartly marketed, film could enjoy a warm reception offshore among upscale auds who groove on well-honed Gallic fare.

Pic was warmly received at its Montreal fest world preem, and copped a shared best actress award for stars Sandrine Kiberlain, Nicole Garcia and Mathilde Seigner, as well as the Fipresci (international critics’ association) award.

Much like Bertrand Tavernier, Miller has essayed a range of character-driven material during his career with no apparent common thread. However, helmer’s long-term fascination with female protags, young people and the crime genre clearly found fertile ground in Ruth Rendell’s “The Tree of Hands,” basis for his script.

Miller learned of the British crime novelist (similar to U.S. writer Patricia Highsmith) after seeing Claude Chabrol’s adaptation of one of her novels (“La ceremonie”), and being attracted to her combo of character, atmosphere and psychology. Like Chabrol, Miller has left no trace of the book’s Brit origins in his totally convincing re-working, set in a comfy Paris suburb.

Opening, shot in blurry, tinted video, immediately establishes a nervy feel as a woman in a train compartment attacks her daughter with a pair of scissors.

Segueing via the scar on the latter’s hand, pic smoothly moves forward some years (and into sharp, clear 35mm) as Betty (Kiberlain), with her young son, Joseph (Arthur Setbon), meets her mother, Margot (Garcia), who’s arrived on a flight from New York.

Betty is enjoying fame from her first novel, but seems ill-at-ease in her mom’s company. The motor-mouthed Margot is a mix of maternal fussing, self-blame and envy.

Scarcely before the movie has begun, Miller throws the viewer for a further loop with the first of many inter-titles that pepper the pic — in this case, “The Story of Joseph.” In rapid strokes, viewer learns that Betty herself has only been back from the States a few weeks, and that she lives in an outwardly genteel suburb, Vaucresson, following a split with Joseph’s father. Then, Joseph falls out a window and is taken unconscious to hospital, where he dies.

As Betty faints in the hospital, a young kid Joseph’s age, Jose (Alexis Chatrian), is lead away by a black man. Another inter-title announces “Jose’s Story.”

Like a ball bouncing off another pool table, pic introduces a whole sub-set of characters centered around a bar in a nearby shopping mall. The black man turns out to be Francois (popular Quebecois singer Luck Mervil), current partner of Carole (Seigner), a strung-out waitresss with a young son, Jose. Hovering around the bar is an Armenian gangster who’s just bought a hotel in town, and Alex (Edouard Baer), a bum-cum-gigolo who may or may not be Jose’s father.

Margot, stricken with guilt at Betty’s depression after the death of her son, casually “borrows” a replacement child for her. The kid is Jose and, even when Betty discovers Margot’s crime, she goes along with it.

Thence begins a labyrinthine tale that fans out further to include Russian money-laundering, a property scam, a curious romance between Betty and the hospital doctor, and even — over an hour in — the sudden appearance of Betty’s ex (Stephane Freiss). The pot is finally brought to the boil in the final section, “The Last Day.”

By starting the movie in an edgy, impressionistic manner, Miller preps the viewer for the increasingly bizarre events to come, making them believable at least within the off-center universe he’s created. Extremely dense, compact script moves with incredible forward momentum, never giving an iota more info than it wants to at any one time and thoroughly involving the viewer in its rapidly spun web. Though the audience always feels led by the nose, it’s a journey worth taking.

Pic’s tone and atmosphere are diametrically opposite to Miller’s previous theatrical feature, the delicately wrought mood piece, “Class Trip” (1998), but there’s the same absolute confidence in leading the audience into a real-looking but totally constructed universe. Performances are such that, even though some characters’ paths hardly cross, there’s a sense of broad ensemble, from Kiberlain’s initially abstracted, later complicit Betty, through Garcia’s initially agitated, later caring mother, to the denizens of the mall bar, led by Seigner’s hard-ass waitress to Mervil’s sympathetic, put-upon lover.

Christophe Pollock’s lensing captures the cold, gray hues of the wintry suburb in the weeks leading to Christmas, and brief uses of classical extracts (a Bach prelude, a Chopin ballade) create moments of repose amid the tangled lives unspooling on screen.

Betty Fisher and Other Stories



A UFD (in France)/Alliance Atlantis Vivafilm (in Canada) release of a UGC YM, Les Films de la Boissiere (France)/Go Films (Canada) production, in association with France 2 Cinema, with participation of Canal Plus. (International sales: President Films, Paris.) Produced by Annie Miller, Yves Marmion. Executive producer, Miller. Co-producer, Nicole Robert. Directed, written by Claude Miller, based on the novel "The Tree of Hands" by Ruth Rendell.


Camera (color), Christophe Pollock; editor, Veronique Lange; music, Francois Dompierre; art director, Jean-Pierre Kohut Svelko; costume designer, Jacqueline Bouchard; sound (Dolby Digital/DTS Digital), Claude La Haye; assistant director, Laure Prevost; casting, Frederique Moidon. Reviewed at Montreal Film Festival (competing), Sept. 1, 2001. Running time: 102 MIN.


Betty Fisher - Sandrine Kiberlain Margot Fisher - Nicole Garcia Carole Novacki - Mathilde Seigner Francois Diembele- Luck Mervil Alex Basato - Edouard Baer Edouard - Stephane Freiss Dr. Jerome Castang - Roschdy Zem Jose Novacki - Alexis Chatrian Joseph Fisher - Arthur Setbon Rene the Canadian - Yves Jacques Mme. Barsky- Consuelo de Haviland Martinaud - Clovis Cornillac Gallien- Yves Verhoeven Jacqueline - Annie Mercier
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety