You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Bella Ciao

A fable about the vitality of immigrants who believe in liberty and love, "Bella Ciao" is as clumsy as it is earnest. Uncomfortable mix of whimsy and political didacticism almost works thanks to talented and dependable cast. But even the playing of Jacques Gamblin and Jalil Lespert can't elevate this one above the nice-but-misguided category.

With:
With: Jacques Gamblin, Yael Abecassis, Jalil Lespert, Serge Hazanavicius, Isabelle Carre, Vahina Giocante, Oceane Mozas, Vittoria Scognamiglio.

A fable about the vitality of immigrants who believe in liberty and love, “Bella Ciao” is as clumsy as it is earnest. Uncomfortable mix of whimsy and political didacticism almost works thanks to talented and dependable cast. But even the playing of Jacques Gamblin and Jalil Lespert — as father and grown son — can’t elevate this one above the nice-but-misguided category.

When the fascists take over Italy in the early ’30s, ardent communists Nella and Orfeo Mancini (Yael Abecassis, Gamblin) leave for America with their young son and daughter but mistakenly get off the boat in Marseilles. School teacher Orfeo becomes a day laborer for a well-connected fellow countryman (Serge Hazanavicius) who was a rival for Nella and soon will be wearing one of Mussolini’s black shirts. The Mancinis are dirt poor — dad even feeds them spoonfuls of Tuscan soil — but they live in a lively immigrant quarter overflowing with storybook-caliber mutual support. As ugly events intervene, subsequent generations are born, each inching up the social ladder. Sun-kissed lensing and nostalgic score can’t mask the structural problems of Stephane Giusti’s quasi-poetic sophomore effort, following the gay comedy “Why Not Me?” (1999).

Bella Ciao

France

Production: An Elzevir Films presentation of an Elzevir Films/France 3 Cinema production, with participation of Canal Plus. (International sales: Art Box, Paris.) Produced by Marie Masmonteil, Denis Carot, Caroline Adrian. Directed by Stephane Giusti. Screenplay, Giusti, Raphaelle Desplechin.

Crew: Camera (color), Jacques Bouquin; editor, Catherine Schwartz; music, Lazare Boghossian; art director, Gerald Eauritte; costume designer, Catherine Rigault. Reviewed at UGC Danton, Paris, June 25, 2001. Running time: 103 MIN.

With: With: Jacques Gamblin, Yael Abecassis, Jalil Lespert, Serge Hazanavicius, Isabelle Carre, Vahina Giocante, Oceane Mozas, Vittoria Scognamiglio.

More Film

  • Madrid’s ECAM Pacts With Torino, Rotterdam

    ECAM Pacts with Torino, Rotterdam on First Incubator Projects

    A fable about the vitality of immigrants who believe in liberty and love, “Bella Ciao” is as clumsy as it is earnest. Uncomfortable mix of whimsy and political didacticism almost works thanks to talented and dependable cast. But even the playing of Jacques Gamblin and Jalil Lespert — as father and grown son — can’t […]

  • Andrew DuncanMomentum Pictures with The Cinema

    'Florida Project' Producer Steps Down Amid Harassment Claims

    A fable about the vitality of immigrants who believe in liberty and love, “Bella Ciao” is as clumsy as it is earnest. Uncomfortable mix of whimsy and political didacticism almost works thanks to talented and dependable cast. But even the playing of Jacques Gamblin and Jalil Lespert — as father and grown son — can’t […]

  • 'Antiporno' Review

    Film Review: 'Antiporno'

    A fable about the vitality of immigrants who believe in liberty and love, “Bella Ciao” is as clumsy as it is earnest. Uncomfortable mix of whimsy and political didacticism almost works thanks to talented and dependable cast. But even the playing of Jacques Gamblin and Jalil Lespert — as father and grown son — can’t […]

  • Nicholas Hoult Current War

    Film News Roundup: Shooting Wraps on Nicholas Hoult's 'Tolkien' Biopic

    A fable about the vitality of immigrants who believe in liberty and love, “Bella Ciao” is as clumsy as it is earnest. Uncomfortable mix of whimsy and political didacticism almost works thanks to talented and dependable cast. But even the playing of Jacques Gamblin and Jalil Lespert — as father and grown son — can’t […]

  • Disney-Fox Deal Casts Future of Fox

    Disney-Fox Deal Casts Future of Fox Studio Lot Into Doubt

    A fable about the vitality of immigrants who believe in liberty and love, “Bella Ciao” is as clumsy as it is earnest. Uncomfortable mix of whimsy and political didacticism almost works thanks to talented and dependable cast. But even the playing of Jacques Gamblin and Jalil Lespert — as father and grown son — can’t […]

  • Loveless Movie Wild Bunch

    Oscars: Nine Films Advance in Foreign-Language Race

    A fable about the vitality of immigrants who believe in liberty and love, “Bella Ciao” is as clumsy as it is earnest. Uncomfortable mix of whimsy and political didacticism almost works thanks to talented and dependable cast. But even the playing of Jacques Gamblin and Jalil Lespert — as father and grown son — can’t […]

  • Andy Muschietti

    'It' Director Andy Muschietti Eyed for 'Electric State' From Russo Brothers

    A fable about the vitality of immigrants who believe in liberty and love, “Bella Ciao” is as clumsy as it is earnest. Uncomfortable mix of whimsy and political didacticism almost works thanks to talented and dependable cast. But even the playing of Jacques Gamblin and Jalil Lespert — as father and grown son — can’t […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content