Crix deliver fascinating mix

Whether yay or nay, 'A.I.' has 'em talking

HOLLYWOOD – “A.I.” is a fascinating movie for the ages and a total winner.

“A.I.” is a frustrating tower of high expectations that collapses into a rubble of dashed hopes.

Take your pick.

America’s critics seem divided between the two mindsets, creating a dissonance seldom heard about a movie with a $100 million pricetag.

Newspapers vary in range from “a complete bust” (St. Paul Pioneer Press) to “the best fairy tale Mr. Spielberg has made” (an unusually gushy New York Times).

No wonder. The pair of directors responsible for its conception and gestation were the oddest of odd couples.

Or, as Stephen Hunter of the Washington Post put it, “Spielberg sees the glass as half full; Kubrick saw the glass smashed and ground into your face.”

The reviews have a common thread regarding the Kubrick Factor. Did Spielberg get it right? Or was Kubrick correct in not making it? Some, like the Orlando Sentinel, bitch amusingly that Spielberg’s direction of the Kubrick project is “like Santa Claus taking charge of the IRS.”

Fascination overload

But whatever camp critics belong to, “A.I.” is certainly generating a surfeit of fascination in their ranks.

n The Washington Post: “Fascinating, if uneven and silly.”

n Rolling Stone: “A fascinating wreck.”

n Variety‘s chief critic Todd McCarthy: “Deeply thoughtful and thoroughly fascinating.”

n The Village Voice: “Fascinatingly schizoid.”

“Fascinating…” is also the first car in a freight train of adjectives proffered by the L.A. Daily News, which also calls it “frustrating.”

Which is about the only other thing on which critics can agree: “A.I.” often frustrates.

n “It exhilarates, frustrates and provokes,” says Newsweek’s David Ansen.

n The pic is “both wonderful and maddening,” grouses Roger Ebert of the Chicago Sun-Times.

n It’s “involving and exasperating,” laments the Philapdelphia Inquirer.

n The Seattle Times, too, has its own appreciative vexation: “For every moment it frustrates, there are a dozen that amaze …”

Yet it’s the ever-abbreviated USA Today that offers perhaps the most concise “A.I.” dictum:

“A movie to be knocked, chewed and gummed,” says USA Today’s critic Mike Clark, “but not dismissed.”

In short, their confusion is real. A consensus it is not.

More Film

  • Anita Hill

    Anita Hill Chairs Hollywood Anti-Sexual Harassment Commission Formed by Top Execs

    HOLLYWOOD – “A.I.” is a fascinating movie for the ages and a total winner. “A.I.” is a frustrating tower of high expectations that collapses into a rubble of dashed hopes. Take your pick. America’s critics seem divided between the two mindsets, creating a dissonance seldom heard about a movie with a $100 million pricetag. Newspapers […]

  • Warren Beatty

    Arnon Milchan Sues Warren Beatty Over 'Rules Don't Apply' Flop

    HOLLYWOOD – “A.I.” is a fascinating movie for the ages and a total winner. “A.I.” is a frustrating tower of high expectations that collapses into a rubble of dashed hopes. Take your pick. America’s critics seem divided between the two mindsets, creating a dissonance seldom heard about a movie with a $100 million pricetag. Newspapers […]

  • Oscar Isaac Addams Family

    Oscar Isaac in Talks to Voice Gomez Addams in Animated 'Addams Family' Movie

    HOLLYWOOD – “A.I.” is a fascinating movie for the ages and a total winner. “A.I.” is a frustrating tower of high expectations that collapses into a rubble of dashed hopes. Take your pick. America’s critics seem divided between the two mindsets, creating a dissonance seldom heard about a movie with a $100 million pricetag. Newspapers […]

  • Jennifer Lawrence

    Publicists for Jennifer Lawrence, Daisy Ridley, Amy Adams Form New Firm

    HOLLYWOOD – “A.I.” is a fascinating movie for the ages and a total winner. “A.I.” is a frustrating tower of high expectations that collapses into a rubble of dashed hopes. Take your pick. America’s critics seem divided between the two mindsets, creating a dissonance seldom heard about a movie with a $100 million pricetag. Newspapers […]

  • Hannah Marks Liana Liberato

    Hannah Marks, Liana Liberato to Star in High School Comedy 'Banana Split'

    HOLLYWOOD – “A.I.” is a fascinating movie for the ages and a total winner. “A.I.” is a frustrating tower of high expectations that collapses into a rubble of dashed hopes. Take your pick. America’s critics seem divided between the two mindsets, creating a dissonance seldom heard about a movie with a $100 million pricetag. Newspapers […]

  • NOR_D01_053017_9621_R2 – L-R: Tom Hanks (Ben

    Steven Spielberg's 'The Post' to Open Palm Springs Film Festival

    HOLLYWOOD – “A.I.” is a fascinating movie for the ages and a total winner. “A.I.” is a frustrating tower of high expectations that collapses into a rubble of dashed hopes. Take your pick. America’s critics seem divided between the two mindsets, creating a dissonance seldom heard about a movie with a $100 million pricetag. Newspapers […]

  • Willa Fitzgerald

    'The Goldfinch' Movie Adaptation Casts Willa Fitzgerald (EXCLUSIVE)

    HOLLYWOOD – “A.I.” is a fascinating movie for the ages and a total winner. “A.I.” is a frustrating tower of high expectations that collapses into a rubble of dashed hopes. Take your pick. America’s critics seem divided between the two mindsets, creating a dissonance seldom heard about a movie with a $100 million pricetag. Newspapers […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content