The Music Man

Norman Rockwell is finally getting some respect in the arts pages, so the time is perhaps ripe for a Broadway revival of Meredith Willson’s 1957 smash “The Music Man,” a theatrical slice of cherry pie that both sends up and pays tribute to the old-fashioned manners and mores of small-town America.

With:
Conductor - Andre Garner
Charlie Cowell - Ralph Byers
Traveling Salesmen - Liam Burke, Kevin Bogue, E. Clayton Cornelious, Michael Duran, Blake Hammond, Michael McGurk
Harold Hill - Craig Bierko
Olin Britt - Michael-Leon Wooley
Amaryllis - Jordan Puryear
Maud Dunlop - Martha Hawley
Ewart Dunlop - Jack Doyle
Mayor Shinn - Paul Benedict
Alma Hix - Leslie Hendrix
Ethel Toffelmeier - Tracy Nicole Chapman
Oliver Hix - John Sloman
Jacey Squires - Blake Hammond
Marcellus Washburn - Max Casella
Tommy Djilas - Clyde Alves
Marian Paroo - Rebecca Luker
Mrs. Paroo - Katherine McGrath
Winthrop Paroo - Michael Phelan
Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn - Ruth Williamson
Zaneeta Shinn - Kate Levering
Gracie Shinn - Ann Whitlow Brown
Mrs. Squires - Ann Brown
Constable Locke - Kevin Bogue

Norman Rockwell is finally getting some respect in the arts pages, so the time is perhaps ripe for a Broadway revival of Meredith Willson’s 1957 smash “The Music Man,” a theatrical slice of cherry pie that both sends up and pays tribute to the old-fashioned manners and mores of small-town America. The author couldn’t ask for a more respectful production than the one lovingly directed and choreographed by Susan Stroman. This happy, hummable, picture-book-pretty show brings the musical-theater season to a close on a sugar high, and should be a hit with summer tourists and family audiences. Adults of a sophisticated bent are not encouraged to attend without kiddie escorts, however, and cynics will need to have their blood-sugar levels checked at regular intervals.

This is indubitably not a high-concept revival that attempts to uncover new subtleties or mine contemporary nuances in a classic show. Indeed, Stroman & Co. are so wary of taking risks with this beloved material that the show’s appealing young star, Craig Bierko, often seems to be channeling Robert Preston, whose performance in the original is the stuff of Broadway legend. But the conservative approach is understandable: Under the whipped-cream surface delights of “The Music Man” lies only more whipped cream, and there’s little sense in pretending otherwise.

The sweet-talking, bad-boy hero of “The Music Man” is Harold Hill, as most of America surely knows. He’s the traveling salesman who rides into River City, Iowa, and proceeds to hornswoggle the gullible townsfolk into buying a wagonfull of horns in order to keep the kids out of trouble. Making trouble for Harold is the suspicious spinster librarian, Marian Paroo (Rebecca Luker), who knows Harold’s a charlatan but nevertheless gradually melts under his vigorous charms as he whips the stiff, slumbering town into a musical frenzy. The show is a sepia-toned tribute to the power of make-believe, and make-believe puts everything right in the end.

“Trouble,” of course, is the first big number in Willson’s infectious choo-choo train of a score. The composer’s musical gifts were of a modest if appealing kind — he wrote great ditties, above all — but his lyrics are wonderfully bubbly and inventive (rhyming “Marian” and “librarian” with “carrion,” of all things). Voices in “The Music Man” act as an entire orchestra: drums, horns, strings and piano, and not just in the bouncy “Seventy Six Trombones,” in which Hill sets all the kids booming, bellowing and blowing on imaginary instruments. Elsewhere singers mimic the rhythms of a chugging train and the pecking of hens, and some of Willson’s snap-crackle-pop vocal arrangements may almost be seen as Broadway precursors of rap. Who’d have thought it?

The score is well served by the show’s stars. (Heavy amplification, the bane of the Broadway theater, is a considerable blight on this production, but it’s more the dialogue than the songs that suffer, thankfully.) Bierko, a Harold Hill firmly in the familiar mold, has a handsome and expressive face, with big blue eyes and leaping eyebrows that disappear regularly under the brim of his straw boater. His vocal style and physical manner are facsimiles of Preston’s — if you can’t beat him, be him, the thinking seems to be. Bierko does, however, have a supple singing voice, and his performance, whatever its provenance, is in the end a thoroughly charming and even affecting one.

Luker’s singing is simply sublime. She has one of the prettiest and most polished soprano voices to be heard on a Broadway stage right now, and ample opportunity to display it here, since Marian is more often than not to be found leaning against a post on the porch, with Peter Kaczorowski’s elegantly dappled moonlight swimming around her, singing one of Willson’s tender ballads. (The finest of these, “My White Knight,” may have been ghostwritten by Frank Loesser, Willson’s mentor, who encouraged him to turn his autobiography into a musical.) Marian, the archetypal good girl, who gives piano lessons when she’s not at the library and has never been to the town’s local dallying spot, is not an easy role to pull off, but Luker infuses it with real, honest feeling, neither pumping up nor patronizing the role’s old-fashioned primness.

Indeed, the marvel of Stroman’s production is that none of the sugar in the show turns to saccharine, none of the characters turn to cardboard, none of the creamed-corn jokes land with too resonant a thud. The book’s simple plot is at least watertight, and thus holds up better than most of its era, and while none of the gags will challenge the sensibilities of a moderately hip 10-year-old, they raise a few real smiles.

The supporting cast of comic characters are well-played, with Ruth Williamson particularly florid as the mayor’s wife, the memorably monikered Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn. Katherine McGrath, a wonderful actress often seen as San Diego’s Old Globe Theater, is dry and funny — and oh so Irish — as Marian’s mother.

The production is certainly easy on the eyes. William Ivey Long’s costumes are an eye-catching parade in themselves, from Harold’s snazzy vanilla ice-cream suits to the fantastically feathered chapeaux of the “Pickalittle” ladies. Thomas Lynch’s pastel-pretty sets make subtle allusions to American art from Rockwell to Andrew Wyeth to Jackson Pollock.

And Stroman’s choreography is, of course, a delectable asset to the production. The three major production numbers — “Seventy Six Trombones,” “Marian the Librarian” and “Shipoopi” — all have their own particular flavor, and Stroman can array dancers on a stage with incomparable, airy finesse. But her work here isn’t as inspired as in “Contact” or the London production of “Oklahoma!” It’s pretty and even intoxicating at times, but it’s all frosting. This is probably because the material isn’t as rich — how much dramatic texture and feeling, after all, can you get into a song called “Shipoopi”? Still, a freer hand (and some minor cutting) might have resulted in a fresher-feeling, zippier and more imaginative show.

Tellingly, all of those qualities are in evidence in Stroman’s finale, the evening’s most inspired moment, which arrives after the curtain has gone down on the show’s happy ending. The details of this number — a kissing cousin of George Balanchine’s “Stars and Stripes” — are too delicious to spoil, but it’s marked by the kind of freewheeling, spirited novelty that marks her best work. That spirit is largely held in check for the duration of the show proper — clearly Stroman reveres “The Music Man” too much to take serious liberties with it.

With Stroman’s staging including gags referring to “American Gothic” and the famous oil of Washington crossing the Delaware, a case is subtly being made for “Music Man” as a classic piece of American art. Maybe it is, maybe it isn’t. But the result is more a perfect reproduction than a classic reinvented. This is a reverent, impeccably staged revival, which would be satisfying if it didn’t come from a woman who might be capable of creating a truly inspired and inspiring one.

The Music Man

Neil Simon Theater; 1,330 seats;$85 top

Production: A Dodger Theatricals, John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, Elizabeth Williams/Anita Waxman, Kardana-Swinsky Prods., Lorie Cowen Levy/Ded Harris presentation of a musical in two acts with book, music and lyrics by Meredith Willson. Story by Willson and Franklin Lacey. Directed and choreographed by Susan Stroman.

Creative: Sets, Thomas Lynch; costumes, William Ivey Long; lighting, Peter Kaczorowski; sound, Jonathan Deans; production supervisor, Steven Zweigbaum; musical supervision and direction, David Chase; orchestrations, Doug Besterman; dance and incidental music arrangements, David Krane; music coordinator, John Miller. Opened April 27, 2000. Reviewed April 25. Running time: 2 HOURS, 45 MIN.

Cast: Conductor - Andre Garner
Charlie Cowell - Ralph Byers
Traveling Salesmen - Liam Burke, Kevin Bogue, E. Clayton Cornelious, Michael Duran, Blake Hammond, Michael McGurk
Harold Hill - Craig Bierko
Olin Britt - Michael-Leon Wooley
Amaryllis - Jordan Puryear
Maud Dunlop - Martha Hawley
Ewart Dunlop - Jack Doyle
Mayor Shinn - Paul Benedict
Alma Hix - Leslie Hendrix
Ethel Toffelmeier - Tracy Nicole Chapman
Oliver Hix - John Sloman
Jacey Squires - Blake Hammond
Marcellus Washburn - Max Casella
Tommy Djilas - Clyde Alves
Marian Paroo - Rebecca Luker
Mrs. Paroo - Katherine McGrath
Winthrop Paroo - Michael Phelan
Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn - Ruth Williamson
Zaneeta Shinn - Kate Levering
Gracie Shinn - Ann Whitlow Brown
Mrs. Squires - Ann Brown
Constable Locke - Kevin Bogue
With: Cameron Adams, Sara Brenner, Chase Brock, Andre Garner, Ellen Harvey, Mary Illes, Joy Lynn Matthews, Robbie Nicholson, Ipsita Paul, Pamela Remler, Dan Sharkey, Lauren Ullrich, Travis Wall.

More Legit

  • Pinocchio review

    London Theater Review: 'Pinocchio'

    Norman Rockwell is finally getting some respect in the arts pages, so the time is perhaps ripe for a Broadway revival of Meredith Willson’s 1957 smash “The Music Man,” a theatrical slice of cherry pie that both sends up and pays tribute to the old-fashioned manners and mores of small-town America. The author couldn’t ask […]

  • The Children review

    Broadway Review: 'The Children'

    Norman Rockwell is finally getting some respect in the arts pages, so the time is perhaps ripe for a Broadway revival of Meredith Willson’s 1957 smash “The Music Man,” a theatrical slice of cherry pie that both sends up and pays tribute to the old-fashioned manners and mores of small-town America. The author couldn’t ask […]

  • Marilyn Stasio's 10 Best New York

    10 Best New York Theater Productions of 2017

    Norman Rockwell is finally getting some respect in the arts pages, so the time is perhaps ripe for a Broadway revival of Meredith Willson’s 1957 smash “The Music Man,” a theatrical slice of cherry pie that both sends up and pays tribute to the old-fashioned manners and mores of small-town America. The author couldn’t ask […]

  • Adam Driver

    Adam Driver to Star in 'Burn This' on Broadway

    Norman Rockwell is finally getting some respect in the arts pages, so the time is perhaps ripe for a Broadway revival of Meredith Willson’s 1957 smash “The Music Man,” a theatrical slice of cherry pie that both sends up and pays tribute to the old-fashioned manners and mores of small-town America. The author couldn’t ask […]

  • The Twilight Zone review

    London Theater Review: 'The Twilight Zone'

    Norman Rockwell is finally getting some respect in the arts pages, so the time is perhaps ripe for a Broadway revival of Meredith Willson’s 1957 smash “The Music Man,” a theatrical slice of cherry pie that both sends up and pays tribute to the old-fashioned manners and mores of small-town America. The author couldn’t ask […]

  • HadestownNew York Theatre WorkshopBy Anaïs MitchellDeveloped

    Streaming to Broadway: How New Titles, Talent Grow Buzz Online

    Norman Rockwell is finally getting some respect in the arts pages, so the time is perhaps ripe for a Broadway revival of Meredith Willson’s 1957 smash “The Music Man,” a theatrical slice of cherry pie that both sends up and pays tribute to the old-fashioned manners and mores of small-town America. The author couldn’t ask […]

  • Chrissy Metz

    Chrissy Metz to Star in Neil LaBute's 'Fat Pig' at Geffen Playhouse

    Norman Rockwell is finally getting some respect in the arts pages, so the time is perhaps ripe for a Broadway revival of Meredith Willson’s 1957 smash “The Music Man,” a theatrical slice of cherry pie that both sends up and pays tribute to the old-fashioned manners and mores of small-town America. The author couldn’t ask […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content