You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

What I Saw in Hebron

The 1929 massacre of Sepharadic Jews by their Arab neighbors is remembered in "What I Saw in Hebron" from Israeli husband-and-wife team Dan and Noit Geva. Potent subject makes this docu worthwhile for select broadcast and educational outlets, even if somewhat uneven execution suggests this historical chapter's definitive screen investigation still lies ahead.

With:
(Hebrew and Arabic dialogue)

The 1929 massacre of Sepharadic Jews by their Arab neighbors is remembered in “What I Saw in Hebron” from Israeli husband-and-wife team Dan and Noit Geva. Potent subject makes this docu worthwhile for select broadcast and educational outlets, even if somewhat uneven execution suggests this historical chapter’s definitive screen investigation still lies ahead.

After the birth of her first child, Noit Geva’s father gave her a distinctive gift: Her late grandmother’s eyewitness account of the massacre of Jewish villagers in 1929 Hebron, written the day afterward by the then 16-year-old Zemira. In pic’s powerful first half, that testimony, read in voiceover, is abetted by those of surviving peers, contemporary footage of the pogrom’s grisly aftermath and creepy latterday prowls through the disaster’s little-changed sites.

For decades, even centuries, Jews and Arabs had co-existed peaceably in the region. But the arrival of Zionist immigrants stoked paranoia, which was then set aflame by planted rumors of anti-Muslim violence in Jerusalem. Women, infants, clergy, friends and neighbors weren’t spared in a two-hour melee that left 67 dead, many more raped or wounded. Several level-headed Arabs did help hide or protect Jews (including the grandmother herself). But others gave themselves over to a collective, feverish brutality — far from cold-blooded executions, the attacks were often grotesquely sadistic, their memory all the more disturbing for being witnessed and recalled by (now-elderly) children.

Impact is somewhat dissipated by second half, in which Noit’s invasive narration, plus the limited insights afforded by variably prejudiced/conciliatory interviewees on both sides, add up to a rote sigh at slim chance for peace in strictly-segregated modern Hebron. Rather banal approach is underlined by predictable scoring choices (mostly Pachelbel’s overexposed Canon in D) and a final chorus of conflicting voices accompanying UNICEF poster-like views of multiethnic children. Tech aspects are OK, some amateurish camerawork aside.

What I Saw in Hebron

Israel

Production: A Noga Communications, Israeli Film Service and Jerusalem Cinematheque production. Produced, directed, edited by Dan and Noit Geva. Screenplay, research, Noit Geva.

Crew: Camera (color/B&W, 16mm), Dan Geva, Gabriel Vagnon; sound, Hadas Leora; associate producer, Michael Avraham. Reviewed on videocassette, San Francisco, July 12, 2000. (In S.F. Jewish Film Festival.) Running time: 73 MIN.

With: (Hebrew and Arabic dialogue)

More Film

  • Amanda Fuller's Thriller 'Fashionista' Bought by

    Film News Roundup: Amanda Fuller's Thriller 'Fashionista' Bought by Freestyle

    The 1929 massacre of Sepharadic Jews by their Arab neighbors is remembered in “What I Saw in Hebron” from Israeli husband-and-wife team Dan and Noit Geva. Potent subject makes this docu worthwhile for select broadcast and educational outlets, even if somewhat uneven execution suggests this historical chapter’s definitive screen investigation still lies ahead. After the […]

  • Sundance 2018: Where Are the Masterpieces?

    Sundance 2018: Where Are the Masterpieces? Sorry, There Are None (Opinion)

    The 1929 massacre of Sepharadic Jews by their Arab neighbors is remembered in “What I Saw in Hebron” from Israeli husband-and-wife team Dan and Noit Geva. Potent subject makes this docu worthwhile for select broadcast and educational outlets, even if somewhat uneven execution suggests this historical chapter’s definitive screen investigation still lies ahead. After the […]

  • EDITORIAL USE ONLY / NO MERCHANDISINGMandatory

    Bradford Dillman, Star of 'Compulsion,' Dies at 87

    The 1929 massacre of Sepharadic Jews by their Arab neighbors is remembered in “What I Saw in Hebron” from Israeli husband-and-wife team Dan and Noit Geva. Potent subject makes this docu worthwhile for select broadcast and educational outlets, even if somewhat uneven execution suggests this historical chapter’s definitive screen investigation still lies ahead. After the […]

  • Duke Nukem

    John Cena in Talks to Star in 'Duke Nukem' Movie

    The 1929 massacre of Sepharadic Jews by their Arab neighbors is remembered in “What I Saw in Hebron” from Israeli husband-and-wife team Dan and Noit Geva. Potent subject makes this docu worthwhile for select broadcast and educational outlets, even if somewhat uneven execution suggests this historical chapter’s definitive screen investigation still lies ahead. After the […]

  • 'And Breathe Normally' Review: Sundance Film

    Sundance Film Review: 'And Breathe Normally'

    The 1929 massacre of Sepharadic Jews by their Arab neighbors is remembered in “What I Saw in Hebron” from Israeli husband-and-wife team Dan and Noit Geva. Potent subject makes this docu worthwhile for select broadcast and educational outlets, even if somewhat uneven execution suggests this historical chapter’s definitive screen investigation still lies ahead. After the […]

  • Baby Driver

    'Baby Driver,' 'Dunkirk,' 'Shape of Water' Lead Golden Reel Nominations for Sound

    The 1929 massacre of Sepharadic Jews by their Arab neighbors is remembered in “What I Saw in Hebron” from Israeli husband-and-wife team Dan and Noit Geva. Potent subject makes this docu worthwhile for select broadcast and educational outlets, even if somewhat uneven execution suggests this historical chapter’s definitive screen investigation still lies ahead. After the […]

  • The Guilty

    Sundance: Magnolia Buys 'The Guilty'

    The 1929 massacre of Sepharadic Jews by their Arab neighbors is remembered in “What I Saw in Hebron” from Israeli husband-and-wife team Dan and Noit Geva. Potent subject makes this docu worthwhile for select broadcast and educational outlets, even if somewhat uneven execution suggests this historical chapter’s definitive screen investigation still lies ahead. After the […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content