Review: ‘Murmur of Youth’

Adelicate portrayal of youthful loneliness and the fragile bond that grows between two adolescent girls with the same given name, "Murmur of Youth" is another exactingly crafted drama from thesp-turned-helmer Lin Cheng-sheng. While perhaps too cool and contained in mood to break new ground for Taiwanese cinema offshore, pic should win friends at many fests, especially those with Asian or gay themes. The gay tag is a bit deceptive, though, because the sexual angle here is slight and almost incidental to a tale focused on evanescent emotional transitions that bring together two girls from opposite sides of the Taipei tracks.

Chen Mei-li (Rene Liu) comes from a middle-class family in which the father is embittered and distant, the mother preoccupied with her own worries. Lin Mei-li (Tseng Tsing) lives in more threadbare but warmer circumstances. Her dad’s a supportive construction worker; her grandmother, the family matriarch, clings to nostalgic dreams of her long-dead husband.

Helmer Lin spends pic’s first hour carefully sketching the characters and milieus of the two Mei-lis (the name means pretty). As in other Taiwanese films, including Lin’s well-received 1996 debut, “A Drifting Life,” the approach is oblique and atmospheric, balancing a melancholic view of family relations with a portrayal of individual lives that stresses the inscrutable ways of fate.

Eventually, as Lin draws together his dramatic threads, the girls end up working with each other in the close confines of a movie theater box office. There, talk of their families, of work and school and other mundane matters leads to more intimate topics, including boys, sex and (in dialogue that’s striking for its length, detail and psychological resonance) menstruation.

While this growing closeness does result in a sexual encounter, the fleeting incident is anything but the tale’s point. Rather, it sensitively redirects the viewer’s attention toward the themes — the mesh of family, society and individual — that have been building throughout. The final effect is both thoughtful and quietly moving.

Though Lin’s spare, nuanced style, with its motionless camera, naturalistic photography and avoidance of music, owes obvious debts to certain senior Taiwanese directors, he exercises it with impressive authority and conviction. Especially compelling are the vibrant, finely shaded perfs he gets from Liu and Tseng as the Mei-lis.

Tech credits are equally strong, with special kudos going to Tsai Cheng-hui’s ace lensing.

Murmur of Youth



A Central Motion Picture (Taipei) presentation. Produced by Hsu Li-kong, Chiu Shun-ching. Executive producer, Chung Hu-ping. Directed by Lin Cheng-sheng. Screenplay, Ko Shu-ching, Lin


Camera (color), Tsai Cheng-hui; editors, Chen Hsiao-tung, Chen Li-yu; composer, Chang Hongyee; music, Bobby Chen; production design, Kuo Chuan-chiu; art direction, Tsai Zao-yi; sound, Hu Din-i; associate producer, Wang Shi-fang; assistant director, Lin Chi-hsiang. Reviewed at Cannes Film Festival (Directors Fortnight), May 11, 1997. Running time: 105 MIN.


Chen Mei-li ..... Rene Liu Lin Mei-li ..... Tseng Tsing Chen's Father ..... Tsai Chin Hsin Chen's Mother ..... Lin Hsui Grandma ..... Grandma Pi
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety