Upon being dumped by his impatient wife, Johnny begins to date Lisa (Lisa LoCicero), a former high school classmate who works as a waitress. Johnny is eager for their friendship to evolve into love and long-term commitment, while Lisa is more comfortable with a more casual and frankly carnal relationship. Even so, she accepts when he offers to lend her money, and encourages his romantic overtures.
The more possessive Johnny becomes, the more uncomfortable Lisa gets. It helps not at all that, when introduced at a party, members of their respective families do not hit it off. Lisa’s slatternly mother thinks Johnny’s family is connected to the mob. This does not stop her however, from enjoying a brief tryst with one of Johnny’s uncles during the party.
Eventually, Johnny grows so jealous and controlling that Lisa is forced to break off their relationship. This cues a terribly rapid change in Johnny, causing him to turn into a bullying, foul-mouthed stalker. He becomes so unstable that, during a typical day of coping with apathetic students, he turns on the class with a viciously insulting tirade, triggering his suspension from teaching duties. And that, unfortunately, gives him all the more time to stew over his breakup with Lisa.
As “Mr. Vincent” charts Johnny’s evolution from generous suitor to vengeful stalker, Hughes’ performance is chillingly persuasive. As Lisa, LoCicero must work with a less well-defined character — occasionally, the pic hints she really is a gold-digger — but she is never less than convincing as she conveys rage and fear.
In a few key scenes, “Mr. Vincent” recalls the raw emotional verisimilitude of works by John Cassavetes. Dick Fisher’s no-frills black-and-white cinematography enhances the credibly edgy mood.
Ultimately, the film chooses to stop short of the tragic conclusion that much of the drama seems to foreshadow. While making an admirable attempt to avoid cliches, however, Celestino strains credibility. The ending appears to indicate that the best way to get romantic obsession out of your system is through an angry act of vandalism. After that, you can go back to being a relatively normal, or least non-threatening, person.
As Woody Allen noted in “Annie Hall” — “If only life were like this!”