Review: ‘Eighteen Springs’

After her 1984 feature "Love in a Fallen City," Hong Kong filmmaker Ann Hui again adapts the work of the late, highly regarded Chinese novelist Eileen Chang. A melancholy melodrama about thwarted love and injurious emotional choices in '30s Shanghai, "Eighteen Springs" boasts a strong cast, handsome production values and solid, if conventional, direction, but fails to ignite the passion required to propel it far beyond Chinatown circuits. Scattered festival bookings should follow nonetheless. Central couple are Manzhen (Wu Chien-lien) and Shijun (Leon Lai), who meet in Shanghai through Shijun's friend Shuhui (Wang Lei) and swiftly fall in love. The first of many obstacles is placed in their path by Shijun's parents back in Nanjing, who intend for him to marry a wealthy girl from the same city (Annie Wu). She instead develops a romantic affinity with Shuhui, who backs off because of his class inferiority.

Further problems arise from Manzhen’s scruples about the taint on Shijun’s name that would come from marriage into her family, given the reputation of her older sister Manlu (Anita Mui), who is a sought-after courtesan. Forced into prostitution to support her family following the death of her father, Manlu is now hard, embittered and pushing 30. She agrees to marry creepy businessman Hongcai (Ge You), despite the fact that repeated abortions have left her unable to bear children. When Hongcai starts hankering for Manzhen and proposes taking her as his concubine and the mother of his children, Manlu colludes in the plan in order to save her marriage.

Hui and scripter Chan Kin-chung could have made the story more resonant for Western audiences by placing it more firmly within its socio-historical context: The Japanese presence in China at that time, and the resulting repression, is touched on only in passing.

But despite its slow pace and somewhat stolid feel, the film remains engrossing thanks to some fine players, drawn from Hong Kong, Taiwan and mainland China. Wu (“Eat Drink Man Woman”) and Cantopop star Lai bring poignancy to the plight of the unfulfilled lovers, and the pairing of consummate actors Mui and mainlander Ge (“To Live”) provides some real pleasures. Lenser Lee Ping-bin’s elegant framing adds distinction to the classy production. Chinese title roughly means “Half a Lifetime’s Romance,” under which English name Chang’s novel is also known.

Eighteen Springs

Hong Kong


A Mandarin Films production. Produced by Raymond Wong, Leung Fung-yee. Executive producers, Ann Hui, Wang Yu. Directed by Ann Hui. Screenplay, Chan Kin-chung, based on the novel by Eileen Chang.


Camera (color), Lee Ping-bin; editors, Wong Yee-shun, Poon Hung; music, Ye Xiaogang; art direction, Bruce Yu, Yank Wong; costume design, Eddie Mok. Reviewed at Vancouver Film Festival, Oct. 5, 1997. (Also in Pusan Film Festival, South Korea.) Running time: 123 MIN.


Shen Shijun ..... Leon Lai Gu Manzhen ..... Wu Chien-lien Gu Manlu ..... Anita Mui Zhu Hongcai ..... Ge You Xu Shuhui ..... Wang Lei Shi Cuizhi ..... Annie Wu Zhang Yujin ..... Wang Zhiwen
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety