Critics’ Tally

“Smokey Joe’s Cafe” opened March 2,1995, at the Virginia Theater to nine favorable reviews (Barnes, Post; Cagle, WCBS-AM; Corliss, Time; Hamburg, WOR-AM; Kissel, Daily News; Klein, WNYW-TV; Sommers, Newhouse Papers; Stearns, USA Today; Torre, New York 1-TV) and six mixed (Brantley, Times; Cunningham, WCBS-TV; Feldberg, Bergen Record; Kuchwara, AP; Lindstrom, WNBC-TV; Winer, New York Newsday).

More Legit

  • Adam Driver

    Adam Driver to Star in 'Burn This' on Broadway

    “Smokey Joe’s Cafe” opened March 2,1995, at the Virginia Theater to nine favorable reviews (Barnes, Post; Cagle, WCBS-AM; Corliss, Time; Hamburg, WOR-AM; Kissel, Daily News; Klein, WNYW-TV; Sommers, Newhouse Papers; Stearns, USA Today; Torre, New York 1-TV) and six mixed (Brantley, Times; Cunningham, WCBS-TV; Feldberg, Bergen Record; Kuchwara, AP; Lindstrom, WNBC-TV; Winer, New York Newsday).

  • The Twilight Zone review

    London Theater Review: 'The Twilight Zone'

    “Smokey Joe’s Cafe” opened March 2,1995, at the Virginia Theater to nine favorable reviews (Barnes, Post; Cagle, WCBS-AM; Corliss, Time; Hamburg, WOR-AM; Kissel, Daily News; Klein, WNYW-TV; Sommers, Newhouse Papers; Stearns, USA Today; Torre, New York 1-TV) and six mixed (Brantley, Times; Cunningham, WCBS-TV; Feldberg, Bergen Record; Kuchwara, AP; Lindstrom, WNBC-TV; Winer, New York Newsday).

  • HadestownNew York Theatre WorkshopBy Anaïs MitchellDeveloped

    Streaming to Broadway: How New Titles, Talent Grow Buzz Online

    “Smokey Joe’s Cafe” opened March 2,1995, at the Virginia Theater to nine favorable reviews (Barnes, Post; Cagle, WCBS-AM; Corliss, Time; Hamburg, WOR-AM; Kissel, Daily News; Klein, WNYW-TV; Sommers, Newhouse Papers; Stearns, USA Today; Torre, New York 1-TV) and six mixed (Brantley, Times; Cunningham, WCBS-TV; Feldberg, Bergen Record; Kuchwara, AP; Lindstrom, WNBC-TV; Winer, New York Newsday).

  • Chrissy Metz

    Chrissy Metz to Star in Neil LaBute's 'Fat Pig' at Geffen Playhouse

    “Smokey Joe’s Cafe” opened March 2,1995, at the Virginia Theater to nine favorable reviews (Barnes, Post; Cagle, WCBS-AM; Corliss, Time; Hamburg, WOR-AM; Kissel, Daily News; Klein, WNYW-TV; Sommers, Newhouse Papers; Stearns, USA Today; Torre, New York 1-TV) and six mixed (Brantley, Times; Cunningham, WCBS-TV; Feldberg, Bergen Record; Kuchwara, AP; Lindstrom, WNBC-TV; Winer, New York Newsday).

  • 'Death Becomes Her' Musical in Development

    'Death Becomes Her' Musical in Development for Kristin Chenoweth

    “Smokey Joe’s Cafe” opened March 2,1995, at the Virginia Theater to nine favorable reviews (Barnes, Post; Cagle, WCBS-AM; Corliss, Time; Hamburg, WOR-AM; Kissel, Daily News; Klein, WNYW-TV; Sommers, Newhouse Papers; Stearns, USA Today; Torre, New York 1-TV) and six mixed (Brantley, Times; Cunningham, WCBS-TV; Feldberg, Bergen Record; Kuchwara, AP; Lindstrom, WNBC-TV; Winer, New York Newsday).

  • Stagecraft podcast John Leguizamo

    Stagecraft Podcast: John Leguizamo Says He's a 'True Ghetto Nerd'

    “Smokey Joe’s Cafe” opened March 2,1995, at the Virginia Theater to nine favorable reviews (Barnes, Post; Cagle, WCBS-AM; Corliss, Time; Hamburg, WOR-AM; Kissel, Daily News; Klein, WNYW-TV; Sommers, Newhouse Papers; Stearns, USA Today; Torre, New York 1-TV) and six mixed (Brantley, Times; Cunningham, WCBS-TV; Feldberg, Bergen Record; Kuchwara, AP; Lindstrom, WNBC-TV; Winer, New York Newsday).

  • The Go-Go's

    Go-Go's Musical 'Head Over Heels,' Produced by Gwyneth Paltrow, Targets Broadway for 2018-19

    “Smokey Joe’s Cafe” opened March 2,1995, at the Virginia Theater to nine favorable reviews (Barnes, Post; Cagle, WCBS-AM; Corliss, Time; Hamburg, WOR-AM; Kissel, Daily News; Klein, WNYW-TV; Sommers, Newhouse Papers; Stearns, USA Today; Torre, New York 1-TV) and six mixed (Brantley, Times; Cunningham, WCBS-TV; Feldberg, Bergen Record; Kuchwara, AP; Lindstrom, WNBC-TV; Winer, New York Newsday).

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content