Review: ‘Rough Magic’

There's not quite enough magic in Clare Peploe's uneven but mostly engaging set-in-Mexico road movie. A terrific perf from Bridget Fonda and charismatic support from Russell Crowe are the chief assets in this mixture of romance, fun and inanity.

There’s not quite enough magic in Clare Peploe’s uneven but mostly engaging set-in-Mexico road movie. A terrific perf from Bridget Fonda and charismatic support from Russell Crowe are the chief assets in this mixture of romance, fun and inanity.

In adapting British crime writer James Hadley Chase’s neatly titled “Miss Shumway Waves a Wand,” director Peploe and her two script collaborators have come up with a somewhat creaky vehicle that is thoroughly entertaining when it works at full cylinder but dismayingly off-key when it doesn’t.

It’s 1950, and political power brokers have their eyes on Cliff Wyatt as future presidential material; described as “smooth as butter and good-looking as Clark Gable,” the wealthy Wyatt (D.W. Moffet is suitably slimy) is heir to priceless uranium mines, but is handicapped by the fact that he isn’t married. An unlikely alliance is forged with orphaned, virginal Myra Shumway, who works as assistant to a magician, and has learned some amazing tricks of her own.

When Myra sees Wyatt in his true colors, she high-tails it to Mexico with a roll of film incriminating her former finance in the slaying of the magician. She aims to find a famous shaman, supposedly older than Columbus, who lives in a temple in a remote part of the country. Wyatt, meanwhile, sends an agent to locate Myra and the film.

The agent turns out to be Alex Ross (Russell Crowe), a jaded newspaperman who never recovered from witnessing the aftermath of the bombing of Nagasaki. He’s turned into a drifter, with an eye for the main chance. Myra also stumbles upon a down-and-out English doctor, Ansell (Jim Broadbent), who’s also interested in the shaman. The trio head for the old wizard’s jungle hideout, with Wyatt and other assorted baddies on their trail.

After a slightly shaky opening, in which Peploe doesn’t quite bring off the world of the magician and his rapport with Myra, pic settles into an enjoyable, if old-fashioned, road pic with Fonda and Crowe making an attractive team as opposites who are gradually attracted to one another on the journey south. In a nod to genre films of another era. Alex refers to Myra as Slim. The finale, which tips into way-out fantasy and comedy, is brightly handled, but the film’s overall tone remains uneven and uncertain, and the introduction of a talking dog is likely to provoke unintended guffaws.

“Rough Magic” is a handsome production, with costume designer Richard Hornung deserving special kudos for the snappy threads and great hats in which Fonda appears in the latter half of the film. Special effects, involving the film’s magical elements, are well executed. But the disparate elements don’t mesh together as well as they should.

Rough Magic



A UGC presentation of a UGC Images (Paris)/Recorded Picture Co. (London) co-production. Produced by Laurie Parker, Declan Baldwin. Executive producers, Yves Attal, Andrew Karsch, Jonathan Taplin. Directed by Clare People. Screenplay, Peploe, Robert Mundy, William Brookfield, from the book "Miss Shumway Waves a Wand," by James Hadley Chase.


Camera (Technicolor), John J. Campbell; editor, Suzanne Fenn; music, Richard Rartley; production design, Waldemar Kalinowski; costumes, Richard Hornung; assistant director, Sebastian Silva; casting, Elisabeth Leustic. Reviewed at Venice Film Festival (Fast Lane), Sept. 2, 1995. Running time: 104 MIN.


Myra Shunway - Bridget Fonda
Alex Ross - Russell Crowe
Doc Ansell - Jim Broadbent
Cliff Wyatt - D.W. Moffet
Diego - Paul Rodriguez
Diego's wife/Tojola - Euva Anderson
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety