To Be or Not to Be

With the solid farcical underpinning of Ernst Lubitsch's 1942 To Be or Not to Be, Mel Brooks' glossy remake of the original Carole Lombard-Jack Benny starrer is very funny stuff indeed.

With:
Mel Brooks Anne Bancroft Tim Matheson Charles Durning Jose Ferrer George Gaynes

With the solid farcical underpinning of Ernst Lubitsch’s 1942 To Be or Not to Be, Mel Brooks’ glossy remake of the original Carole Lombard-Jack Benny starrer is very funny stuff indeed.

Maintaining some of the dramatic core of the original, but played mostly for Brooks-style laughs, the convoluted tale of a Warsaw theatrical troupe that winds up saving the Polish underground during the Nazi occupation does have some potential hurdles to clear. Cute Nazis and roly-poly Gestapo officers hardly have universal lure.

Brooks sustains, with varying success, a full-fledged role as Frederick Bronski, vainglorious head of a tawdry theatrical company whose shows run the spectrum from cheap vaudeville turns to Highlights from Hamlet. Mainstay of the film is a superbly sustained comic performance by Anne Bancroft, as Bronski’s wife, in the real-life Brooks couple’s first tandem co-starring acting job.

Charles Durning is a standout as the buffoonish Gestapo topper and Bancroft’s pseudo-seduction of him, and Nazi hireling Jose Ferrer, are among the pic’s highpoints. Bancroft’s sustained delights are not matched by Brooks, who seems to be trying too hard.

1983: Nomination: Best Supp. Actor (Charles Durning)

To Be or Not to Be

Production: Brooksfilms. Director Alan Johnson; Producer Mel Brooks; Screenplay Thomas Meehan, Ronny Graham; Camera Gerald Hirschfeld; Editor Alan Balsam; Music John Morris; Art Director Terence Marsh

Crew: (Color) Available on VHS, DVD. Extract of a review from 1983. Running time: 108 MIN.

With: Mel Brooks Anne Bancroft Tim Matheson Charles Durning Jose Ferrer George Gaynes

More Film

  • SAG Awards Snubs and Suprises

    SAG Nominations: 16 Biggest Snubs and Surprises

    With the solid farcical underpinning of Ernst Lubitsch’s 1942 To Be or Not to Be, Mel Brooks’ glossy remake of the original Carole Lombard-Jack Benny starrer is very funny stuff indeed. Maintaining some of the dramatic core of the original, but played mostly for Brooks-style laughs, the convoluted tale of a Warsaw theatrical troupe that […]

  • Three Billboards Stranger Things

    SAG Award Nominations Scorecard: Fox Searchlight, Netflix Top List

    With the solid farcical underpinning of Ernst Lubitsch’s 1942 To Be or Not to Be, Mel Brooks’ glossy remake of the original Carole Lombard-Jack Benny starrer is very funny stuff indeed. Maintaining some of the dramatic core of the original, but played mostly for Brooks-style laughs, the convoluted tale of a Warsaw theatrical troupe that […]

  • Lady Bird Three Billboards

    SAG Awards: Are 'Lady Bird' and 'Three Billboards' Your New Oscar Frontrunners?

    With the solid farcical underpinning of Ernst Lubitsch’s 1942 To Be or Not to Be, Mel Brooks’ glossy remake of the original Carole Lombard-Jack Benny starrer is very funny stuff indeed. Maintaining some of the dramatic core of the original, but played mostly for Brooks-style laughs, the convoluted tale of a Warsaw theatrical troupe that […]

  • Rupert Murdoch Bob Iger Disney Fox

    Disney-Fox Deal: 10 Burning Questions as Takeover Deal Looms

    With the solid farcical underpinning of Ernst Lubitsch’s 1942 To Be or Not to Be, Mel Brooks’ glossy remake of the original Carole Lombard-Jack Benny starrer is very funny stuff indeed. Maintaining some of the dramatic core of the original, but played mostly for Brooks-style laughs, the convoluted tale of a Warsaw theatrical troupe that […]

  • Three Billboards Stranger Things SAG Nominations

    Screen Actors Guild Award Nominations: 'Three Billboards' Dominates, 'The Post' Shut Out

    With the solid farcical underpinning of Ernst Lubitsch’s 1942 To Be or Not to Be, Mel Brooks’ glossy remake of the original Carole Lombard-Jack Benny starrer is very funny stuff indeed. Maintaining some of the dramatic core of the original, but played mostly for Brooks-style laughs, the convoluted tale of a Warsaw theatrical troupe that […]

  • Olivia Munn Niecy Nash

    SAG Award Nominations: Complete List

    With the solid farcical underpinning of Ernst Lubitsch’s 1942 To Be or Not to Be, Mel Brooks’ glossy remake of the original Carole Lombard-Jack Benny starrer is very funny stuff indeed. Maintaining some of the dramatic core of the original, but played mostly for Brooks-style laughs, the convoluted tale of a Warsaw theatrical troupe that […]

  • Sag Awards Preview

    How to Watch the SAG Awards Nominations Live

    With the solid farcical underpinning of Ernst Lubitsch’s 1942 To Be or Not to Be, Mel Brooks’ glossy remake of the original Carole Lombard-Jack Benny starrer is very funny stuff indeed. Maintaining some of the dramatic core of the original, but played mostly for Brooks-style laughs, the convoluted tale of a Warsaw theatrical troupe that […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content