You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Fanny by Gaslight

Unfortunately, Anthony Asquith's direction is hurt by faulty film editing and irritatingly slow tempo. Although the script distorts the original story almost beyond recognition, there is still retained a lot of plot development in the house of ill-fame, which in the book is the main background. For all its being toned down from Michael Sadleir's frank treatment in the novel, the way the curvaceous femmes do their stuff in the underground joint hardly makes for best family trade.

With:
Phyllis Calvert James Mason Wilfrid Lawson Stewart Granger Jean Kent Margaretta Scott

Unfortunately, Anthony Asquith’s direction is hurt by faulty film editing and irritatingly slow tempo. Although the script distorts the original story almost beyond recognition, there is still retained a lot of plot development in the house of ill-fame, which in the book is the main background. For all its being toned down from Michael Sadleir’s frank treatment in the novel, the way the curvaceous femmes do their stuff in the underground joint hardly makes for best family trade.

As a matter of fact, the film would suffer little if all the bawdy-house sequences were removed. The main theme – the thorny path traveled by the true lovers because the man is ‘well born’ while the girl is an illegitimate child, foster-fathered by the bawdy housekeeper – would be preserved by the mid-Victorian pillorying they both receive.

With so many good performances, it is significant that Phyllis Calvert in the lead more than holds her own. She succeeds in portraying Fanny with girlish wistfulness and appeal.

Fanny by Gaslight

UK

Production: Gainsborough. Director Anthony Asquith; Producer Edward Black; Screenplay Doreen Montgomery, Aimee Stuart; Camera Arthur Crabtree; Editor R.E. Dearing; Music Cedric Mallabey; Art Director John Bryan

Crew: (B&W) Available on VHS. Extract of a review from 1944. Running time: 108 MIN.

With: Phyllis Calvert James Mason Wilfrid Lawson Stewart Granger Jean Kent Margaretta Scott

More Film

  • Zoe Ewan McGregor

    Tribeca Film Review: 'Zoe'

    Unfortunately, Anthony Asquith’s direction is hurt by faulty film editing and irritatingly slow tempo. Although the script distorts the original story almost beyond recognition, there is still retained a lot of plot development in the house of ill-fame, which in the book is the main background. For all its being toned down from Michael Sadleir’s […]

  • James Cameron Pandora World of Avatar

    James Cameron Talks Plans for Five 'Avatar' Films & More 'Terminator'

    Unfortunately, Anthony Asquith’s direction is hurt by faulty film editing and irritatingly slow tempo. Although the script distorts the original story almost beyond recognition, there is still retained a lot of plot development in the house of ill-fame, which in the book is the main background. For all its being toned down from Michael Sadleir’s […]

  • Rampage

    Dwayne Johnson's 'Rampage' Continues to Roar Overseas

    Unfortunately, Anthony Asquith’s direction is hurt by faulty film editing and irritatingly slow tempo. Although the script distorts the original story almost beyond recognition, there is still retained a lot of plot development in the house of ill-fame, which in the book is the main background. For all its being toned down from Michael Sadleir’s […]

  • No Merchandising. Editorial Use Only. No

    Box Office: 'A Quiet Place' Back on Top, 'Super Troopers 2' Smokes Projections

    Unfortunately, Anthony Asquith’s direction is hurt by faulty film editing and irritatingly slow tempo. Although the script distorts the original story almost beyond recognition, there is still retained a lot of plot development in the house of ill-fame, which in the book is the main background. For all its being toned down from Michael Sadleir’s […]

  • 'The Night Eats the World' Review

    Tribeca Film Review: 'The Night Eats the World'

    Unfortunately, Anthony Asquith’s direction is hurt by faulty film editing and irritatingly slow tempo. Although the script distorts the original story almost beyond recognition, there is still retained a lot of plot development in the house of ill-fame, which in the book is the main background. For all its being toned down from Michael Sadleir’s […]

  • Bradley Cooper Robert De Niro

    Bradley Cooper on His Secret Pact With Lady Gaga for 'A Star is Born'

    Unfortunately, Anthony Asquith’s direction is hurt by faulty film editing and irritatingly slow tempo. Although the script distorts the original story almost beyond recognition, there is still retained a lot of plot development in the house of ill-fame, which in the book is the main background. For all its being toned down from Michael Sadleir’s […]

  • The seagull

    Tribeca Film Review: 'The Seagull'

    Unfortunately, Anthony Asquith’s direction is hurt by faulty film editing and irritatingly slow tempo. Although the script distorts the original story almost beyond recognition, there is still retained a lot of plot development in the house of ill-fame, which in the book is the main background. For all its being toned down from Michael Sadleir’s […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content