Review: ‘Duck Soup’

Practically everybody wants a good laugh right now and "Duck Soup" should make practically everybody laugh. It is humorous in the typical Marx Bros. style, a style that happens to be popular. Picture should draw and please all over.

Practically everybody wants a good laugh right now and “Duck Soup” should make practically everybody laugh. It is humorous in the typical Marx Bros. style, a style that happens to be popular. Picture should draw and please all over.

The laughs come often, too often sometimes, which has always been the case with Marx talkers, although in this instance more care appears to have been taken with the timing, since the step-on gags don’t occur as frequently as in the past. But a picture that contains enough howls to lose some of them without the losses being noticed needn’t fret.

Less gags this trip with more accent on ‘situation.’ That doesn’t hurt, either. Radio has killed all the good gags and is responsible for the present low caste of gagsters and gags. The shift to the ‘situation’ in this picture therefore is a relief besides being, for the Marxes, a means of changing the pace that will draw dividends for the boys in the future.

In place of the constant punning and dame chasing, “Duck Soup” has the Marxes madcapping through such bits as the old Schwartz Bros. mirror routine, so well done in the hands of Groucho, Harpo and Chico that it gathers a new and hilarious comedy momentum all over again.

Story is a mythical kingdom burlesque that could easily have been written by a six-year-old with dust in his eyes, but it isn’t so much the story as what goes with and on within it. Groucho is the prime minister, who takes his job as seriously as a judge in “Irish Justice,” and gives this champ of comedy dialog a veritable Yankee Stadium to work in. For his customary dowager-foil he has the high, wide and handsome Margaret Dumont, making it perfect for Groucho.

While Groucho soft pedals the verbal clowning for more physical effort this time the other boys also make a quick change. Chico and Harpo omit their musical specialties, which should make it much easier for the piano and harp numbers the next time, if needed. Zeppo is simply Zeppo. Press sheet says, “Zeppo, despite his straight character, is a most important part of the team. He’s an expert gag man and is so splendid at imitating any one of the brothers, that should illness stop one from making an appearance, Zeppo can immediately take his place.” Clearing up that mystery.

Music and lyrics, through which much of the action is in rhyme and song, serve to carry the story along rather than to stand out on pop song merit on their own. Everything’s in keeping with the tempo of the production, the Marxes personally staying on top of the story at all times and on top of the music as well. The biggest slice of songwriting arrives in the heaviest production number, a satirical congressional or parliamentary session in which war is declared.

Everybody in the support cast, excepting Edgar Kennedy, plays straight to the Marxes. Kennedy has two swell sessions with Harpo and Chico.


Duck Soup


Paramount. Director Leo McCarey; Producer [uncredited]; Screenplay Bert Kalmar, Harry Ruby, Arthur Sheekman, Nat Perrin; Camera Henry Sharp; Editor [LeRoy Stone]; Music [Arthur Johnston (adv.)]; Art Director [Hans Dreier, Wiard B. Ihnen]. At Rivoli, N.Y. for grind run Nov. 22.


(B&W) Available on VHS, DVD. Original review text from 1933. Running time: 70 MIN.


Rufus T. Firefly - Groucho Marx Chicolini - Chico Marx Brownie - Harpo Marx Bob Rolland - Zeppo Marx Vera Marcal - Raquel Torres Ambassador Trentino - Louis Calhern Mrs. Teasdale - Margaret Dumont Secretary - Verna Hillie Agitator - Leonid Kinsky Zander - Edmund Breese Secretary of War - Edwin Maxwell Peddler - Edgar Kennedy

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety