You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Sherlock, Jr.

This Buster Keaton feature length comedy is about as unfunny as a hospital operating room.

With:
Buster Keaton Kathryn McGuire Ward Crane Joseph Keaton

This Buster Keaton feature length comedy is about as unfunny as a hospital operating room.

The picture has all the old hoke in the world in it. That ranges from a piece of business with a flypaper to a money-changing bit and, for added good measure, a chase. There are, in fact, two chases; but neither can for a single second hold a candle to Harold Lloyd. In comparison they appear child’s play.

There is one piece of business, however, that is worthy of comment. It is the bit where Buster as a motion-picture machine operator in a dream scene walks out of the booth and into the action that is taking place on the screen of the picture that he is projecting. That is clever. The rest is bunk.

Sherlock, Jr.

Production: Keaton/Metro. Director Buster Keaton; Screenplay Jean Havez, Joseph Mitchell, Clyde Bruckman; Camera Elgin Lessley, Byron Houck; Art Director Fred Gabourie

Crew: Silent. (B&W) Extract of a review from 1924. Running time: 48 MIN.

With: Buster Keaton Kathryn McGuire Ward Crane Joseph Keaton

More Film

  • London Film Festival Director Clare Stewart

    London Film Festival Director Clare Stewart to Take Year-long Sabbatical

    This Buster Keaton feature length comedy is about as unfunny as a hospital operating room. The picture has all the old hoke in the world in it. That ranges from a piece of business with a flypaper to a money-changing bit and, for added good measure, a chase. There are, in fact, two chases; but […]

  • ‘Guilty Men’ Sweeps Colombia's 6th Macondo

    ‘Guilty Men’ Sweeps Colombia's 6th Macondo Awards

    This Buster Keaton feature length comedy is about as unfunny as a hospital operating room. The picture has all the old hoke in the world in it. That ranges from a piece of business with a flypaper to a money-changing bit and, for added good measure, a chase. There are, in fact, two chases; but […]

  • Madrid’s ECAM Pacts With Torino, Rotterdam

    ECAM Pacts with Torino, Rotterdam on First Incubator Projects

    This Buster Keaton feature length comedy is about as unfunny as a hospital operating room. The picture has all the old hoke in the world in it. That ranges from a piece of business with a flypaper to a money-changing bit and, for added good measure, a chase. There are, in fact, two chases; but […]

  • Andrew DuncanMomentum Pictures with The Cinema

    'Florida Project' Producer Steps Down Amid Harassment Claims

    This Buster Keaton feature length comedy is about as unfunny as a hospital operating room. The picture has all the old hoke in the world in it. That ranges from a piece of business with a flypaper to a money-changing bit and, for added good measure, a chase. There are, in fact, two chases; but […]

  • 'Antiporno' Review

    Film Review: 'Antiporno'

    This Buster Keaton feature length comedy is about as unfunny as a hospital operating room. The picture has all the old hoke in the world in it. That ranges from a piece of business with a flypaper to a money-changing bit and, for added good measure, a chase. There are, in fact, two chases; but […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content